SOAPBOX: How fair by-elections can be held when a Councillor or MLA resigns? (Scott Moore)

Scott Moore is a former council election candidate for the Alliance Party from Strabane, speaking in personal capacity. He studies International Politics and Conflict Studies at QUB.

Currently in Northern Ireland, when a Councillor or MLA dies, resigns or otherwise vacates their seat, their party appoints (co-opts) a replacement. Or, in the case of an independent, a substitute is selected from a list provided in advance.

Before the 2016 election, a fifth of MLAs in the Assembly had been co-opted rather than elected. It is not unlikely that politicians have resigned who would not have done so if it meant their party would face a by-election, and the risk of losing the seat.

When a Westminster MP vacates their seat, it is filled via a first-past-the-post by-election, with the same method used for Council seats in Britain, and for constituency seats in other devolved assemblies.

Dáíl Eireann uses ordinary STV by-elections, but these can unfairly change the political balance of a constituency mid-term, giving a disproportionate advantage to the largest parties in a constituency ,  which is why Northern Ireland, to date, has preferred co-option.

From 2011 to 2016, roughly 20% of MLAs vacated their seats, compared to around 2% of MPs from 2010 to 2015 (excluding politicians who died). The fact that MLAs do not have to face a by-election when they vacate their seats, and that the Assembly has a far higher rate of mid-term resignations, is no coincidence.

In general, a politician should serve their full term unless they have a necessary reason for resigning — they should not resign purely for career-related reasons.

Recently, I published a paper: A method for holding fair by-elections in single transferable vote systems. It proposes a modified version of STV, called single transferable vote with differential quotas (STV-DQ), which would allow for fair by-elections to be held for Assembly and District Council seats, and solve the problems affecting ordinary STV in by-elections, giving each party a level playing field and removing the disproportionate advantage for larger parties.

It changes the ordinary STV system in a few ways. Firstly, as the name suggests, STV-DQ gives each candidate a different quota depending on how many seats their party already holds in the area. Secondly, if voters for a large party try to vote for a small party or independent with very similar views in an attempt to exploit their lower quota and thereby get a disproportionate influence on the results, the system will detect this, and apply penalties to even things out.

There are two penalties – a floor penalty, which in principle is applied to parties whose voters transferred to a candidate that was eventually elected and currently holds a seat, to stop them essentially getting to ‘double spend’ their vote; and an increase penalty, applied to those parties that have had an increase in their percentage share of vote if a ‘flight’ of votes is detected from larger parties that already have seats.

All this might sound undemocratic – but in a by-election, it may be a small party’s representative resigning their seat. A large party may already have a number of seats in the area reflecting their share of the vote, and an additional seat would mean they’d be overrepresented. It’s easy to see how this could happen – if PBP MLA Gerry Carroll resigned in West Belfast, and an ordinary STV by-election was held, Sinn Féin would probably win the seat easily – resulting in five out of five Assembly seats in West Belfast for Sinn Féin, despite Sinn Féin having 50-60% of the vote. This would be clearly unfair, and my system would address that unfairness.

When a politician vacates their seat, voters should elect a replacement through a by-election, rather than party officials or members deciding instead. However, this should be subject to the ability of a by-election to produce a fair and democratic result. I do not believe ordinary STV meets that criterion — but that my method, at the very least, provides the basis for a system which does.

I call on all political parties in Northern Ireland to support a review of the co-option procedure, and to consider whether my proposed system would provide the basis for by-elections to be held instead for Assembly and District Council seats that are vacated here.

You can find out a lot more about the detail of my proposals by downloading and reading the full paper.


Discover more from Slugger O'Toole

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

We are reader supported. Donate to keep Slugger lit!

For over 20 years, Slugger has been an independent place for debate and new ideas. We have published over 40,000 posts and over one and a half million comments on the site. Each month we have over 70,000 readers. All this we have accomplished with only volunteers we have never had any paid staff.

Slugger does not receive any funding, and we respect our readers, so we will never run intrusive ads or sponsored posts. Instead, we are reader-supported. Help us keep Slugger independent by becoming a friend of Slugger. While we run a tight ship and no one gets paid to write, we need money to help us cover our costs.

If you like what we do, we are asking you to consider giving a monthly donation of any amount, or you can give a one-off donation. Any amount is appreciated.