|
|
Friday, May 25, 2007
I, like others, gave Sinn Fein a fair chance of taking a serious step forward in this election. But perhaps it is possible that we’ve been viewing them too much through the prisym of their Northern Irish success, and not as they are viewed by southerners. One Northern unionist, Steven King, clinically picks apart Sinn Fein economic policy, what there is of it. He argues it is long on promise of state help, but short on explaining where the money will come from that will pay for it.
Gerry Adams’ foreword to his manifesto lists a 10-point plan. Priority Number 1 is, surprise, surprise, a United Ireland. Priority number 2 is about Partition. A strong economy comes in not 3rd, not 4th but – you guessed it – 10th. According to Sinn Féin, the economic prosperity Ireland now enjoys is down to “the hard work of all our people”. It’s a charming idea – except it presupposes that everyone in Ireland was a work-shy layabout until 15 years ago. Policies had nothing to do with it, apparently.
Sinn Féin makes passing mention of unionists in its plans – a small step forward. But is a party that demands inquiries into abuses by anyone and everyone except the IRA, which goes beyond (and therefore undermines) the Good Friday Agreement, which talks about human rights but has a long history of excusing mass murder, and which (still) has nothing good to say about the Gardai in its manifesto really a party likely to inspire confidence among sections of this island’s population?
Sinn Féin has a glib response to this: if them being in government is good enough for Ian Paisley, it should be more than good enough for everyone else. After all, didn’t unionism take the brunt over the years, without for a moment overlooking the Jerry McCabes, the Billy Foxs and all the rest? But that is to pretend that Dublin and Belfast are just two sides of the same coin when there is, in fact, a world of difference.
The Northern Ireland Executive levies no taxes. It doesn’t determine its own spending. It has no role whatever in foreign affairs or defence. It still has no responsibility for policing and the administration of justice. And there are a whole range of issues it is expressly prohibited from legislating on.
There might be fancy titles and long limousines and a very grand setting but the Northern administration bears closer relation to a county council with attitude than a national parliament. As the Good Friday Agreement states, “Northern Ireland in its entirety remains part of the United Kingdom… [Westminster’s] power to make legislation for Northern Ireland would remain unaffected”. End of story.
Wrap up...
Mick Fealty @ 07:45 AM
Page 1 of 1 pages
|
Nominate Slugger
Slugger O'Toole records news, commentary and diverse opinion on Northern Ireland, the Republic and Britain.
Produced by Mick Fealty
Designed by River Path
Re-designed by Heraghty Web Design
News, tips or crits here: .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) (change "-at-" to "@")
Commenting Policy
Other links:
- (R) registration
- (S) subscription
News:
Resources:
Background:
Media Forum
CAIN
ECONI
NI Elections
Elections Ireland
Peace Polls
Political Betting
UK Polling Reports
Life and Times
Political Demography
Policy Brief
Frontline
A State Apart
World Info
Democratic Dialogue
INCORE
British Irish Studies
Stratagem
Nationalism project
Belfast Agreement
Patten Report
Saville Enquiry
Weblogs:
Mick@theGuardian
O thuaidh:
3000 Versts
A Pint of Unionist Lite
A Tangled Web
Alan in Belfast
Balrog
Bob Balls
Burke's Corner
El Blogador
Balrog
From the Balcony
Green Ribbon
Keith Anderson
Mark Devenport
Matt McDermott
O'Conall Street
Open Unionism
Original Sims
South Belfast Diary
Splintered Sunrise
United Irelander
We perish...
Your friend in the north
Will Crawley
Agus theas:
1169 and counting
Irish Election
Blather
Paschal Donohoe
Damien Mulley
Gerry O'Sullivan Free Stater
Gavin Sheridan
Irish Corruption
Suzy Byrne
Karlin Lillington
Red Mum
Richard Delevan
Rick O'Shea
Sarah Carey
Sinead Gleeson
Tallrite
Other Irish blogs
Scotland:
1820
Brian Taylor
Calum Cashley
Doctor Vee
Ideas of Civilisation
Malc in the Burgh
Moridura
Mr Eugenides
Scottish Unionist Voice
Shuggy
SNP Tactical Voting
Stephen Glenn
Sub Rosa
The Steamie
Torcuil Crichton
Yapping Yousef
England:
Adam Smith blog
Biased BBC
Bloggerheads
Conservative Home
Danny Finkelstein
Dizzy Thinks
Guido
Harry's place
Iain Dale
Liberal Conspiracy
Labour Home
Local Democracy
Never Trust a Hippy
Paul Linford
John Naughton
New Statesman
Normblog
Perfect.co.uk
Political Betting
Nick Robinson
Samizdata
Global Dashboard
Natalie Solent
UK Polling Report
Wardman Wire
Europe:
England Expects
EU Law Blogger
European Tribune
Europhobia
Fistful of Euros
John Worth
Open Europe
State of the Union
The Brussels Journal
Wallstrom
Politicians:
Damien Blake
Joan Burton
Thomas Byrne
Eric Byrne
Lucinda Creighton
Ciaran Cuffe
Liz McManus
Seamus Ryan
Lynne Featherstone
Sandra Gidley
Tom Harris
Boris Johnson
Austin Mitchell
Clive Soley
Tom Watson
Shaun Woodward
Derek Wyatt
World:
Abiole Lapite
Africa Pundit
Agonist
Arts and Letters
Blogcritics
Bloggingheads
Buzz Machine
Crooked Timber
Hit and Run
Daily Kos
Gladwell
Instapundit
Jackie Danicki
Kausfiles
Kevin Drumm
Comes in Pints
Jack O'Toole
Rebecca Blood
Rittenhouse Review
Tim Blair
Smart Mobs
Samuel Pepys
Virginia Postrel
Volokh
World Bank President
Daily Summit
Satire:
Portadown News
Pure Derry
Dangermaus
Langerland
International dialogue:
openDemocracy
Dialog Now
Discussion:
Boards.ie
Debate Central
Republican politics
Derry Forums
Fast Fude
Daltai na Gaeilge
Archives
- March, 2010
- February, 2010
- January, 2010
- December, 2009
- November, 2009
- October, 2009
- September, 2009
- August, 2009
- July, 2009
- June, 2009
- May, 2009
- April, 2009
- March, 2009
- February, 2009
- January, 2009
- December, 2008
- November, 2008
- October, 2008
- September, 2008
- August, 2008
- July, 2008
- June, 2008
- May, 2008
- April, 2008
- March, 2008
- February, 2008
- January, 2008
- December, 2007
- November, 2007
- October, 2007
- September, 2007
- August, 2007
- July, 2007
- June, 2007
- May, 2007
- April, 2007
- March, 2007
- February, 2007
- January, 2007
- December, 2006
- November, 2006
- October, 2006
- September, 2006
- August, 2006
- July, 2006
- June, 2006
- May, 2006
- April, 2006
- March, 2006
- February, 2006
- January, 2006
- December, 2005
- November, 2005
- October, 2005
- September, 2005
- August, 2005
- July, 2005
- June, 2005
- May, 2005
- April, 2005
- March, 2005
- February, 2005
- January, 2005
- December, 2004
- November, 2004
- October, 2004
- September, 2004
- July, 2004
- March, 2004
- October, 2003
- September, 2003
- May, 2003
- Complete Archives
- Category Archives
|