Slugger O'Toole Notes on Northern Ireland politics and culture Slugger O'Toole Notes on Northern Ireland politics and culture

You are here
Home | Society | Why society needs 'degenerate' changemakers...


Next or Previous
« a combination of historical ignorance and monumental self-pity | Main | Remember, violence doesn't pay.. »




SOS - Save Our Slugger!

Help fund Slugger's new software:

Or mail it direct to Slugger!



Why society needs 'degenerate' changemakers...
Or why a healthy society thrives on dissent. And even, who will save us from the stupidity of endless, repetitive order? Fascinating thesis from that most excellent political dissenter John Lloyd, which he kicks off with a seminal quote from Nietzsche:
"The danger to those strong communities founded on homogeneous individuals who have character is growing stupidity, which follows all stability like a shadow. It is the individuals who have fewer ties and are much more uncertain and morally weaker upon whom spiritual progress depends in such communities; they are the men who make new and manifold experiments."

Lloyd argues that every party/tradition, needs a leading dissenter to effect real change. He draws mostly from British parliamentary history, citing D'Israeli, Churchill and Ernest Bevan as prime examples of men who thought and acted across the currents of orthodoxy in their own traditions and in doing so effected substantial and lasting changes.

But his thesis is one that could be fed on and made relevant to the local scene in so many, many ways. Who'll give us a starter for ten?


Comments (3)

Mick,
This is one for me ;)

Must add a section of the 2nd paragraph though:

"People who don’t observe that morality are seen as degenerates, or “morally weaker” - which they are, judged by the morality of the system. But they are also - to repeat a phrase of Tony Blair’s - the “change-makers”.

Now bear in mind Matthew 5:20

"For I say unto you, That except your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees, ye shall in no case enter into the kingdom of heaven" KJV

In this spirit, Jesus condemns the Pharisees, the respectable religious people of his day, for they perform the empty rituals of worship but do not live authentic lives of service to the kingdom of God. Jesus says he has come to bring the kingdom of God to Earth. But the respectable religious and civil leaders of his day do not care for the poor, the downtrodden and the oppressed. They prefer to be seen as respectable, as upholders of the established social, economic and religious order.

Evil presents itself as "respectability," as the established way of doing things, as the accepted social morality of a society. Evil hides, they say, in everydayness, in business as usual, in what is given honors and the highest praise.

Evil poses as its opposite.

Now you don't have to look at this from a religious viewpoint either. Many humanists down through the ages have arrived at this same conclusion.

I would therefore agree with the thesis of John Lloyd; but take it further and say that the "outsiders" the so-called "degenerates" are not "morally weaker" at all, but in every sense morally stronger.

It seems that most "degenerates" have only ever been able to influence from the side-lines, being writers, prophets, musicians.
This is because the "immoral herd" of hypocrits run the system.
The peace-makers of this world: Jesus, Gandhi always get killed.
I've a feeling norn iron is full of these so-called degenerates, which the snobs like to mock and humiliate because they haven't got jobs, are not "respectable"; but actually come from a deeper and better morality than they are being led by.
So up the "moral degenerates" I say. And of course I'm not talking about thugs and arseholes.

Posted by: spirit-level at October 18, 2005 01:40 PM


Posted by: spirit-level at October 18, 2005 02:47 PM


John Lloyd, late of the New Statesman, now at the Financial Times magazins?

The same John Lloyd who recanted his membership of the Communist Party of Great Britain and the British and Irish Communist Organisation?

The same John Lloyd that argued catholics in NI should be discriminated against because they were "disloyal"?

Him?

J...

Posted by: Diarmuid Og at October 18, 2005 03:39 PM



NOTE: When adding hyperlinks, please follow this format:
<a href="(URL)">hyperlink</a>
It is important that you include http:// when adding the URL.

Slugger O'Toole records news, commentary and diverse opinion on Northern Ireland.

Produced by Mick Fealty
Designed by River Path

News, tips or crits here: mick.fealty -at- gmail.com
(change "-at-" to "@")

Commenting Policy


Topics
a long peace?
books
Britain
Conflict
Culture
Economy
Education
election 2003
Election 2005
Enviroment
environment
Europe
Gaeilge
Glossary
Government
Highlights
Human Rights
Humour
International
Manifesto
Media
Nationalism
Negotiations
Parties
Policing
Soapbox
Society
Sport
the south
unionism

Highlights
Out with the crystal ball...
Just a Mo...
Commenting Policy
A backgrounder on the McCartney affair
Northern Bank raid and political fallout, so far

Readers comments
More corrupt than last year? - (4)
Living on an island or in a state? - (31)
a combination of historical ignorance and monumental self-pity - (42)
Payout time... - (4)
New Lansdowne revealed - (24)
Far right 'imagination'... - (13)
Nazi comments were a sectarian slur - (3)
The price of peacemaking... - (17)
belfast metropolitan area plan unveiled - (23)
Why (or rather how) Alec Reid was right... - (37)


Archives
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
July 2004
March 2004
October 2003
September 2003
May 2003



Design: River Path Associates Comments: Big Blog Co Powered: Movable Type 3.15 Copyright © 2003 Sluggerotoole.com All rights reserved.