![]() |
|
You are here Home | Topics | Human Rights
SOS - Save Our Slugger!
Help fund Slugger's new software: Or mail it direct to Slugger! You are here Home | Topics | Human Rights |
August 31, 2005
Another statement Ruaned...SINN Fein has called for eBay to stop selling DVDs of Irish Travellers' bare-knuckle fights. Without a trace of irony, Catriona Ruane stated: "We are against the exploitation of violence in any way... They shouldn't be selling racist incitement to hatred." She obviously hasn't visited Sinn Fein's online shop in a while... Diversity requires a common bottom lineFascinating piece from Martin Wolf at the FT. Evidently he is not thinking of Northern Ireland, but there may be relevant lessons to be drawn from his argument. He praises British multiculturalism but warns that it has limits and that no political entity can hold with a certain number of key requisites to retain the loyality of its entire population: Human beings, said Aristotle, are political animals. For a political community to flourish there must at least be agreement on the rules of the game. The notion of politics here is a broad one. It includes the methods for choosing the holders of executive, judicial and legislative power. It covers what they are entitled to do. It also concerns the rights of individuals against the state and fellow citizens. It concerns, in short, both the legitimacy and limits of power. What was lost in the rejection of SunningdaleVincent Browne, is clearly irked by a reference in a recent Daily Ireland article to Gerry Fitt as an 'Uncle Tomas' figure in Irish nationalism. In response he asks what benefits Nationalism accrued from Sinn Fein and the IRA's rejection of the Sunningdale Agreement (subs needed): ...there are a few elements to the Belfast Agreement that were not in the Sunningdale agreement - a more robust commitment to human rights and a commitment to devolve policing powers, but did they make such a difference? Or more particularly, did the difference go anywhere near justifying the slaughter of more than 1,000 people, the maiming of thousands of others and the ruination of countless lives? What is eating people in Ballymena?The 'troubles' in Ballymena continue with the targeting of a Catholic Primary school on the Cullybackey Road. The article is accompanied by condemnation from Nationalist politicians. It's interesting to note that of all victims of these attacks, 75% were Catholic but, surprisingly perhaps, 25% were protestant. None of the reports we've seen so far seem to get to the heart of what has actually kicked these incidents off in the first place, nor what appear to have sustained them through the summer. Gerry Fitt is laid to restHis funeral took place today at Westminster Cathedral in central London. In the Guardian's report it only mentions the presence of prominent figures from the UUP (Trimble) and SDLP (Durkan and Hume) - are we to assume that no-one from SF or the DUP attended? Rivals unite in tribute to Lord Fitt Press Association Figures from across Northern Ireland's political divide gathered today to pay their respects to former Social Democratic and Labour party (SDLP) leader Lord Fitt. Among the unionists and nationalists gathered for his funeral at London's Westminster Cathedral were the joint Nobel Peace Prize winners, Ulster Unionist David Trimble and the SDLP's John Hume. Also present was Mark Durkin, the current leader of the party Lord Fitt once led. The peer, who died at the age of 79 last week after suffering from a heart condition, helped found the Social Democratic Labour party in 1970 with civil rights and nationalist leaders from the province. Article continues A fierce opponent of terrorism and social injustice alike, Gerry Fitt served as deputy chief executive of Northern Ireland's first power-sharing executive in 1974. He continued to lead the party after the executive - formed out of the 1973 Sunningdale agreement - collapsed after just five months, brought down by a loyalist workers' strike. But in 1979 he dramatically quit his own party after it turned down an offer of talks by the then Conservative government because the agenda did not contain an Irish dimension. His departure followed a period of growing disillusionment with the party which he accused of becoming "green", moving away from the socialism which was Fitt's guiding influence. His political low point came in 1983 when, two years after refusing to support IRA hunger strikers, he lost the West Belfast seat at Westminster, which he had held since 1966, to Sinn Féin's Gerry Adams. Having been wounded by RUC police in a civil rights march in 1968, he found himself burnt-out of his north Belfast home by republicans in 1983. Today he was honoured both by the party from which he had become estranged and rivals from across the political spectrum. Mr Durkin was among those who paid tribute to the former party leader. Speaking just before the service he said: "People who were in the party with him during those years have fond memories of good work together in difficult times. "Obviously there was subsequent differences but we are here to remember a man who contributed positively, a man of warmth and wit." The service, filled with Irish music and poetry, opened as hundreds of mourners sang the ancient hymn Be Thou My Vision. Another hymn, Make Me A Channel Of Your Peace, continued the theme of peace and justice spoken of in the tributes. Among those in the congregation were representatives of the British and Irish governments, MPs including Ulster-born Kate Hoey, and celebrities including the television presenter Henry Kelly and comedian Frank Carson. Readings included a passage from the Book of Wisdom, read by his daughter, Eileen, which included the line: "The souls of the virtuous are in the hands of God and no torment will ever touch them." There was also a reading of The Lake Isle of Innisfree by WB Yates and a violin performance of Danny Boy. But the lightest moment came during a tribute from the journalist Chris Ryder, a close friend, who told of one incident on a flight from London to Belfast when Lord Fitt managed to persuade the crew to let him take the last available seat - the jump seat in the cockpit. Mr Ryder told the congregation: "When he emerged through the door in mid-flight to visit the lavatory, there in the front row was an astonished Reverend Ian Paisley. "'Don't worry, I've left it on automatic pilot,' he told his great political rival as he pushed past."
Clarke candidacy highlights Tory dilemma...Leading on from where Gonzo left off. Clarke is 65, and this is his third bid for the leadership. Precedent suggests he's not well matched to an aging party suspicious of his pro-European views (though he's getting distance between himself and the Euro), and his anti war stance (only five other Tories followed him into the no lobby). But the serial failure of his previous rivals hardly recommends a hard man of the right either. The Times doubts he has the numbers to win. As the Toryleadership blog notes, he's more popular with Labour insiders than Tories. Being attractive to your main opponents can be a political millstone. But it could also be a singular advantage to a party that has failed to make any substantive electoral appeal beyond its own core support for well over a decade. Jackie Ashley (hardly a prospective Tory voter), believes he has the capacity to charm and communicate in a similar manner to the late Mo Mowlam. Presumably he can dispense with the services of whoever coached IDS to that appalling performance in his "quiet man is turning up the volume" speech. Currently the party is split between the modernisers (for whom questions of style are important) and those who believe policy should be the core of their offering. In reality, it's unlikely that the party can have one without the other if it is determined to return to status as Britain's natural party of government. If the Tories were to put Clarke in the hot seat, they might have a a solution to the problem of style. But he will also need a big idea or two to 1, allow him to unify party, and 2, hit Gordon Brown with something that voters will take note of? Those ideas will have to come recognisably from the right (the Nixon and China motif) if he's to achieve the former. And they'll have to have something of the post-Blairite about them to do the latter. See Excerpts from the Mail interview. a state of devastationThat's how the Mayor of New Orleans described the scene as flood levels continue to rise, with 80% of the city already under water. The BBC also report that heavily armed police have been trying to impose a form of martial law to stem outbreaks of looting and that the stadium where 20,000 people were taking refuge is being evacuated. Fuller coverage can be found at, New Orleans newspaper, Times-Picayune website, as the media switches to the web. Also worth reading this Washington Post report on the situation, and this one on the massive relief effort ahead. Sport Benefiting from Economic BoomArticle from Reuters yesterday on cricket in Ireland "there's a slogan to motivate the masses"Courtesy of the excellent Newshound. The rumours of Newton's demise have, clearly, been greatly exaggarated - Quite simple really. 'Love Ulster' is a terror campaign. Not the old kind of terror campaign, mind you but a new political kind aimed at terrifying people into thinking that all those cows are about to stampede north and chew up our passports.Read the rest here Keeping Mediocrity At BayGeorge Ivan Morrison is 60 today [biography here.. wikipedia page here]. And we should be very grateful for him.. and his music. There are some great sites detailing the career of The Man, the official web-site, and this comprehensive fan-site, which includes some of the less difficult interviews he's given. As this BBC report notes, BBC Radio Ulster is marking his musical legacy with a Morrison track every hour, and some dedicated programmes including a two-hour celebration at 8pm, hosted by Stuart Bailie who celebrated the occasion in the Belfast Telegraph at the weekend. There's also a great [but short] snippet of conversation from Van in the Radio2 songlibrary speaking about his musical influences[RealPlayer sound file] Happy Birthday Van. Blair backs banned Muslim scholarIs Tony Blair finally trying to put some 'clear blue water' between himself and the White House given that Professor Tariq Ramadam (who has been banned in the US and France) has been appointed to a government taskforce? Also it sounds like the White House is getting increasingly peeved by the fact that Tony still hasn't gone to pick up his Congressional Gold Medal (highest civilian honour) which he was awarded two years ago. Blair backs banned Muslim scholar Vikram Dodd A Muslim scholar accused by critics of sympathising with violence has been appointed to a government taskforce attempting to root out Islamic extremism in Britain, the Guardian has learned. Professor Tariq Ramadan has been banned from entering the United States and France because of his alleged views supporting violence, allegations he strongly denies. He faced a campaign of vilification from rightwing British newspapers, and last night some saw his inclusion on the group as evidence of the government's willingness to stand up to the tabloids. Article continues The taskforce, known as the working group on tackling extremism, is part of the government's response to the July attacks on London, which was announced by Tony Blair. A source with knowledge of the group's work said its members had been chosen by the Home Office. The 13-member working party will report to the home secretary and prime minister by late September and make proposals to stop British Muslims turning to violence. His supporters say he is one of the leading Islamic thinkers and an important voice in improving relations between Muslims and the west. The academic attended a meeting at the Home Office last week to discuss extremism among British Muslims as part of the group's work. The group is comprised of Muslims from community groups, academics and the MP Shahid Malik, and is staffed by Home Office civil servants. Rightwing newspapers have called for the professor to be banned from Britain because of his alleged views justifying terrorism. Last year he was stopped from taking up a post at a US university after the Bush administration revoked his visa claiming he "endorsed terrorist activity". Yesterday some hailed the appointment of Prof Ramadan to the committee, saying it showed the government was prepared to stand up to rightwing tabloids that had savaged the academic. Sadiq Khan, Labour MP for Tooting, said: "It's important for the government to listen to people who have scholarly knowledge of the issues. "It sends all the right messages that the government is engaged in a real search for answers, rather than pandering to kneejerk elements in the rightwing press and their prejudices." One source present at last week's meeting told the Guardian that Mr Ramadan's contribution was "progressive" and he said there was a real need for Muslims to confront extremism and accept it exists. Another source with knowledge of the setting up of the group said: "He brings understanding of Islam that young people respect." Prof Ramadan has said the French ban on him was successfully challenged in court and he now has an office there. He also says he has been invited to reapply for a US visa. He is based in Switzerland and has lectured to senior police officers in Britain. He recently was appointed a visit fellow at an Oxford University college. The US-based Time magazine hailed him as one of the 21st century's likely innovators. A spokesman for the Board of Jewish Deputies said: "We have urged the government to exercise caution and responsibility in selecting participants for the taskforce which has a crucial role in tackling extremism." Mike Whine, spokesman for the Jewish Community Security Trust which monitors alleged Muslim extremists, said: "It's a strange choice given his past statements which some have viewed as being anti-Jewish. Some of our community view him as extreme. "He speaks with two voices, one for his European audience which appears moderate, and one for his Arab hinterland where he voices many of the demands of Islamists. "He is at the soft end of the Islamist extreme spectrum." Last year Prof Ramadan wrote in the Guardian, defending himself against accusations of extremism, anti-semitism and despising women. He wrote that he has called on Muslims to reject acts of extremism and added: "What about my statements, issued on September 13 2001, calling on Muslims to condemn the terrorist attacks ... What about the articles in which I condemn anti-semitism." A Home Office spokesman would not confirm whether Prof Ramadan was part of the group tackling extremism. The membership is scheduled to be announced this week. The Home Office spokesman said: "It's part of the job of government ministers to talk and consult with people from different communities and that means they will routinely deal with people whose views they do not necessarily agree. The members of the working group are respected members of the Muslim community." Prof Ramadan is scheduled to appear at a Guardian fringe event at the Labour party conference in Brighton on September 28, and has appeared at past events organised by the Guardian with British Muslim communities. Clarke's a Tory rogue..!KEN Clarke is to make another bid for the leadership of the Conservative Party. Do you find him appealing? Oh brother, where art thou..?A COLERAINE couple made medical history today by cryogenically freezing some stem cells from the umbilical tube of their second child in South Africa - genetic insurance policy. They did it in order to treat possible future illnesses or diseases the boy might suffer from. The idea isn't new for 'saviour siblings' (as another NI couple illustrated very recently), but as Marie Foy reports: "What is groundbreaking is the concept of storing stem cells in a perfectly healthy baby in case he or she ever develops illnesses later in life." It's hard to gauge the level of local interest in such a new and potentially revolutionary form of medicine, but the fact that people from NI are prepared to be at the forefront of genetic science is something of a wake-up call to something. To what, you can debate... Time for worried parents with cash to spare to sell the SUV and bank that umbilical cord? August 30, 2005 eppur, si muoveAs Galileo Galilei may, or may not, have said. Worryingly, some people still don't know that it does.. muove, that is - as Instapundit notes, from this profile of political scientist, Dr. Jon D. Miller in the NYT, "One adult American in five thinks the Sun revolves around the Earth.." So, as part of an ongoing effort to avoid a similar situation developing here *ahem* I present the latest Notes on the Solar System. From details of Saturn's moon Enceladus from the Cassini fly-by to how the entire galaxy may come a cropper.. don't worry it's [at least] 5 billion years ahead... much more over the gap The famous quote, and thread title, was reportedly said by Galileo, on 22 June 1633, after he was formally sentenced to life imprisonment [in reality house-arrest] by the Inquistion at the end of his trial for the heresy of holding, defending or teaching that the Earth moves around the Sun - the translation is "yet it moves" [and, incidentially, the heresy related to a book Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems: Ptolemaic and Copernican, which went on sale in March 1632.. two years after its completion, during which time the official censors in Rome only requested some minor changes before they actually approved the text before it went to print]. Three of the ten cardinals present refused to sign the sentence and it was passed on a majority verdict. Galileo was also the first astronomer to note that there was something unusual about the appearance of Saturn, around the time of the publication of The Starry Messenger in 1610, translated extract here.. using a telescope he constructed with a magnifying power of around 20 to 30 times.. although that observational puzzle didn't start to be solved until 1655, when the Dutch scientist Christiaan Huygens realised that it was the result of Saturn having a ring system. ANYway... To today's notes.. The Huygens part of the Cassini-Huygens probe has already done its part, landing on Titan back in January, and the data from then is still being processed. Meanwhile the Cassini orbiter continues to observe and transmit back to Earth. The latest results are from a fly-by of Enceladus in July. Nasa has a collection of the latest images On Monday the orbiter passed Titan again. More information here But the image that would delight Galileo, possibly even more than the others, may be this one of Saturn's ring system in detail, complete with shepherd moon Pan - Pan is only 26 kilometers (16 miles) across - a ring system that has its own atmosphere As for where this leads us.. looking back to see the [possible] future The BBC report is based on the images of two colliding galaxies, approximately 100 million light years away, from the Gemini Observatory - which consists of twin 8-meter optical/infrared telescopes, one located ona mountain, in the Chilean Andes, called Cerro Pachón and the other on Hawaii's Mauna Kea The observatory site has a much better image of the colliding galaxies here.. with a couple of even better images available here That should sort out the science quota for the next week - Ed. Bus Driver Wins Lifesavers AwardA Translink bus driver who saved an 11 year old boy from accidentally hanging himself has been presented with the prestigious Vodafone Northern Ireland Lifesavers accolade. Brian Chambers will now go on to a national shortlist to be judged by a celebrity panel. We wish him luck. Suicides Risen Since Troubles EndSome chilling new figures have been released today. A survey carried out by the University of Ulster and the Department of Psychiatry at the Mater Hospital found that during the worst years of violence, suicides fell significantly but have now risen in a period of relative peace. Researchers believe civil unrest may have strengthened social bonds within communities, and thus "buffered" suicidal thoughts. Parents will have last word on Grammar schoolsNewton Emerson compares the impending reform of the education system - ie the plan to abolish the eleven plus and move towards a comprehensive system - with the coercive integration of black and white children in Kentucky. The Catholic school system, which has already embraced the concept, may be the first victim, as parents move their children to non Catholic Grammar schools in pursuit of the best education on offer. By Newton Emerson: Last November I spent five days in Louisville, Kentucky, a city of a quarter of a million people – and there wasn’t a soul to be seen. The sprawling centre was utterly deserted, with whole buildings simply missing, bizarrely reminiscent of an early-evening control zone in 1980s Belfast. This is the legacy of ‘busing’, the forced racial integration of Louisville’s schools. Since 1975 white children have been sent to black schools and vice versa, by bus and by quota, regardless of the child or the school. As a result everyone who can afford it – black and white - lives outside the city boundaries. At the downtown offices of the Louisville Courier-Journal busing was the first thing the editor explained to us - the key to understanding his city. At the offices of Mayor Jerry Abramson we learned of his campaign to extend those boundaries out beyond the ‘white flight’ suburbs in an attempt at reintegration. Nobody knows if it will work. No ideology, creed or policy yet devised has ever stopped people trying to do the best for their children at a purely individual level. This is the fact that must be acknowledged now in Northern Ireland as our own education system faces imminent change. The cosy consensus of the present arrangement is coming to an end, exposed by early moves towards comprehensive schooling in the Catholic sector. The paradox that has emerged is this: we are told that it is wrong for schools to select children by academic ability. At the same time, we are told that it is right for schools to select children by religious belief. As both these moral arguments are based entirely on the advantages or disadvantages of selection, both cannot simultaneously be true. Where tribal integrity is at stake the people of Northern Ireland will generally accept contradictory positions - but where education is at stake, even the people of Northern Ireland will break rank in numbers. The recent upsurge in Catholic enrolment at state grammar schools proves it, but this may only be the start of our own ‘white flight’. In Britain it has long been considered normal to move house to be near a good school, even if it means less space for more money. This will happen here. In much of England it is normal for families on average incomes to pay for private schooling, even if it means no money for anything else at all. This will happen here too. The Department of Education, the maintained and controlled sectors, the churches, the political parties and the teaching unions can believe, say and do whatever they like. Everyone else will do everything they can to get their children into the best school possible – even if they have to build it themselves. In Louisville people would be amazed to learn that our authorities plan to resolve the selection paradox by abolishing state grammar schools. Coerced integration wouldn’t work in Northern Ireland any better than it worked in America but coerced segregation won’t work either – because the issue for most parents is not integration or segregation, but coercion itself. Vested interests in the present system are already struggling to maintain their agendas. Disgracefully, schools have been exempted from fair employment legislation. The Catholic church actively lobbies against the voluntary integrated sector. Clerics and councillors stuff the boards of state schools, terrified that mixed enrolment will dilute their unofficial ‘Protestant ethos’. Politicians who shamelessly compare themselves to Martin Luther King and Nelson Mandela promote segregation and hiring practices straight from Wallace’s Alabama and de Klerk’s South Africa. Asking parents to accept all this and a failed comprehensive model as well is an ideological step too far - and how ironic that the maintained sector should be the first to feel the squeeze, having single-handedly created the Catholic middle class whose aspirations it now scorns. Most ironic of all is that Northern Ireland already has a working compromise between Catholic, Protestant, grammar and comprehensive in Craigavon’s Dixon Plan. For over 30 years the children of Craigavon, Portadown, Lurgan and Banbridge have been selected by subject-based examination at the age of 14 after three years in comprehensive junior high schools. This ideologically impure system is successful and hugely popular – but only with parents, so during the Costello Report consultation the Department of Education completely ignored it. Alas for those unable to buy their way out of the coming catastrophe, the Department of Education is about to learn that it is only what parents want that matters. First published in the Irish News. Rounders: the fourth Gaelic game...Right, hands up. Who knew that Rounders was one of the four original sports included in the GAA of 1884? Well I didn't. It was only the sport's inclusion as a warm up for one of the recent big games at Croke Park that alerted me to it. It even has its own rules (PDF). It's a popular but mostly informal game in England, although there are over thirty adults teams playing on a regular basis. But is it the same game? And are we likely to see an Ireland vs England international? Remembering Gerry Fitt...Gerry Fitt's death feels like the passing of an era. A world war coloured his political outlook and his perceptions of conflict. Even so, it never took the edge off his performance in the nightly TV jousts with unionist arch rival Ian Paisley of the early seventies - played out largely against a backdrop of murder campaigns, civil bombings and torturous executions. It intimately connected most political players with their respective audiences in a way that few modern politicians can expect nowadays. Fitt chose Bell's Hill in the County of Down as his title in the Lords. It's a small and, otherwise obscure, townland not far from Crossgar. He was evacuated there in the early part of the war, before he was old enough to join the Merchant Navy. It was his first foray outside his own working class Belfast, and perhaps represented a calm before a storm that seemed to stay with him throughout his often tumultuous political career. His former colleague and eventual SDLP successor to his West Belfast, Joe Hendron, compared him in stature to the Nationalist MP Joe Devlin, although Fitt's first pre-occupations upon entering politics revolved more around issues of social justice, rather than Devlin's traditional Nationalism per se. Ruth Dudley Edwards knew the man, and recalls with a typical warts and all account of how they first met in the midst of one the most menancing and dangerous years of the troubles, 1972. Don Anderson in today's Belfast Telegraph probably has the most comprehensive sets of anecdotes, including a possibly mischievious accusation that the apparently teetotal Ian Paisley enjoys a quiet tipple every now and then. Official Republican reaction has been muted for the most part, but much of the resentment emanating from that political quarter centres on Fitt's stand against the Hunger Strikes of 1981 - a stand (also at vairance with his own party) that many believe cost him his West Belfast seat in 1983. However most of the press coverage, focuses on his earlier career and his pivotal role in raising the issue of Civil Rights in Northern Ireland with a wider audience. Even the Newsletter yesterday devoted its leader to an affectionate valedictory to the co-founder and first leader of that alliance of often competing and fractious nationalist interests, the SDLP. His funeral Mass will be in Westminster Cathedral tomorrow at 10.30am. His family have suggested that everyone is welcome. We can't be there, but would respectfully welcome the thoughtful contributions of any of you in a position to attend. There's also a memorial service in Crossgar at 9.30am. Read also: Brian Walker (who reported him most of Fitt's career); the Daily Telegraph's obit recalling the murder of his election agent in 1972; Alasdair Steven (reg needed) on Fitt's middle of the road self diagnosis. Words deployed in new phase of war...THE launch of the 'Love Ulster' unionist campaign against a United Ireland yesterday was steeped in symbolism. Echoing the arrival of the Clyde Valley arms shipment for the UVF at Larne in 1914, Shankill Mirror newspapers were unloaded from a boat at the port yesterday. The aim was - I think - to illustrate that the unionist side of the argument against republicanism was capable of being made through democratic means. Wullie Wilkinson's statement that one of the aims of 'Love Ulster' is to counter republican propaganda would seem to back this. However, the use of loyalist terrorists to distribute the paper throughout NI was disconcerting for many unionists and others. And since when did the UDA give a damn about a free press?! The News Letter reported John McVicar of the Shankill Mirror, one of the chief organisers, saying that the paramilitaries could not be ignored. "The reality is that loyalist paramilitaries are part of the Protestant community," he stressed. "They along with a lot of other people were part of the conflict we have been involved in and they need to be part of the resolution. We have come out of 35 years of violence, things aren't going to change overnight and we need to influence everyone in our community positively and that includes loyalist paramilitaries." Great. Now we have another loyalist Gerry Adams. Of course, it's better that loyalists unloaded a paper cargo and not a metal one, but frankly, no-one would believe any paramilitary who said this was indicative of the direction loyalism is heading in. Evidence on the ground tends to suggest the exact opposite. There is no question of UVF or UDA decommissioning at present, even when both present a much greater threat to both unionists and nationalists than any republican grouping at this time. By heaving bundles of newspapers off a Larne boat, UDA leader Jackie McDonald was perhaps attempting to demonstrate to loyalists that there was now an alternative means of pursuing their political ambitions, other than through violence. Whether loyalist paramilitaries actually have any political pretensions these days is another matter - hard, honest work may not appeal very much to someone dealing drugs or living easily on extorted money, ostensibly in the name of Ulster. The ultimate irony is, of course, that McDonald's UDA is currently going around newsagents' shops every Sunday morning stealing and burning copies of the Sunday World tabloid paper, which lambasts and lampoons loyalist terrorism. So much for supporting a free press Jackie - the campaign should end now if you don't want to look like a completely hypocritical chancer of the first order. Nevertheless, the campaign's deep symbolism seems to amount to an attempt to shift the conflict onto a different level. In a sense, this is simply following the example of the republican movement, which moved the theatre of conflict to other arenas, such as culture, through opposition to Orange marches, for example, or the establishment of Daily Ireland as a means to disseminate republican ideas to a wider audience. Some of the symbolism used in the 'Love Ulster' campaign propaganda is more knowing and historically conscious than most current unionist/loyalist cultural representations, which veers between the arcane quasi-Masonic symbolism of the loyal orders at one end, and the brutal glorification of loyalist violence in murals at the other. For example, the professionally designed 'Love Ulster' poster entitled 'Evil happens when good people do nothing' takes its cue from Edmund Burke, a conservative Anglo-Irish philosopher. It is certainly a more modern, imaginative and subtle effort at propaganda than yesterday's Shankill Mirror front page - 'Ulster at crisis point' - which is such a tired old expression that it has become a worn-out cliche. What surprise lies in store for us next week: 'Ulster at the brink'? The poster also appropriates Martin Niemoeller's poem: First they came for the Communists, but I was not a Communist - so I said nothing. Then they came for the Social Democrats, but I was not a Social Democrat - so I did nothing. Then they came for the trade unionists, but I was not a trade unionist. And then they came for the Jews, but I was not a Jew - so I did little. Then when they came for me, there was no one left who could stand up for me. However, this time the 'victims' are the B-Specials, the UDR, the RUC and now the RIR. Helpfully, unionists aren't asked whether they did anything when 'they' came for others, reinforcing the notion that the State acted solely in defence or was reactive to others' violence. Happily, Niemoeller was a Lutheran and unionists tend to sympathise with Israel in the Middle-East conflict (whereas republicans show solidarity with the Palestinian cause). Remember all the Israeli and Palestinian flags that popped up in Belfast a few years ago? (Unionist icon Carson also appears on the poster, extending a red hand in an angry 'stop' gesture, adding historical authority to the international solidarity. The pose is adapted from his statue outside Stormont's Parliament Buildings, with the original gesture being an upturned hand.) Claiming these culturally iconographic words and appropriating them for the unionist cause, while simultaneously seeking international common cause is perhaps an unexpected move from a unionism that long seemed only capable of being inward-looking. Although there has long been an underlying sympathy and fascination with Israel within Ulster Protestantism, 'Love Ulster' looks like it is extending that remit. The news that unionists are off to Colombia to bring back civilian victims of FARC activity is perhaps another indicator that unionism's real international objective is to cultivate new support in America. Unionists are big fans of George Dubya and his foreign policy, and perhaps see the potential of mining as much 'anti-terror', pro-Israel sentiment in the States as they can while he's in charge. Well if it worked for republicans when Clinton was in power, it must be worth a bash, eh? The trouble with Belfast...For a time, Troubles Tourism (subs needed) did its fair share in attracting the world to its doors. However, according to the New York Times the weekend before last, it's not up to scratch for the modern tourist. The Belfast Telegraph took up the gauntlet with Mary FitzGerald's interview with Alan Clarke, head of Northern Ireland Tourist Board. Its leader went on to argue, that a multiplication in domestic flights into both Belfast airports requires movement beyond old strategies. Getting some decent signs to the National Trust's Divis and Black Mountain walks would help augment the offering. The views over Belfast Lough and Lagan Valley are stunning, but you'd need to be local to find them without risking a massive detour - via Glenavy, or even worse, the International Airport! Belfast's heart of cultural diversity?Not every part of Northern Ireland is divided and contentious territory. Noreen Erskine examines the rising cultural diversity on display in St George's Market in Belfast. Ireland loves its historyJim Duffy, writing in today's Irish Times, sets out the challenge for a 21st Century Ireland that claims to be pluralistic - "Editing the awkward bits out of our national narrative"[subs req.] - an Ireland, as he points out, which "loves its history. But it likes one-sided history. The side may change, depending on each generation's fad, fashion or political correctness." As he says in his concluding paragraph - The task 21st century Ireland faces is to become genuinely pluralist, to find a way to see the full complex story of Ireland; of 1914-1918 and 1916, of poppies and Easter lilies, Pearse and visiting princesses, of preserving and restoring monuments to Queen Victoria and buildings associated with the Easter Rising. An extract from the Irish Times article, since so many can't access it through the subscription barrier - Take the early 20th century myth: how an oppressed Ireland rose up against its British oppressor in 1916. Not exactly. In reality only a tiny fringe rose. Far from having the country behind them, they needed protection from Dublin mobs, while nationalist newspapers called for the execution of Pearse, Connolly and the rest of the leaders. This line, from later in the article, which is worth reading in full, probably best sums up his argument - The irony is that modern Ireland, in its conviction that it is pluralist, plays the same games with its history as it accuses past generations of doing. Fitt recalled with great affection...Despite the political wrangling over the meaning of Gerry Fitt's political career, Laura McDaid in yesterday's Andersonstown News found that ordinary people in West Belfast had little else but praise for a man they remember with great affection. The price of policing..?ALLIANCE leader David Ford has acknowledged that members of the IRA could end up in the police on Inside Politics. Meanwhile, the SDLP appeared even more perturbed than Sammy Wilson over talk of people with terrorist convictions joining the PSNI. Perhaps Sammy - like others - thinks it's a non-starter. Mind you, there must be some republican who watched events unfold in Garnerville recently, and wondered if signing up to policing wasn't such a bad thing after all. Community policing must never have looked so attractive to the IRA... Sammy Wilson of the DUP said: "To be honest, that issue was raised by one member of the board, who suggested that, if we wanted to police the estates effectively, we would have to recruit from those estates, and that might mean considering recruiting some people with terrorist convictions. "But I have to say that there is little enthusiasm that I can detect for that move on the board, and it would mean that the law would have to be changed. "I doubt whether any unionist or SDLP MPs would support Tony Blair, if he introduced a Bill at Westminster to try to bring that about." This has never stopped Tony Blair before, and - if he so chooses - the law won't stop this time either, as he'll just change it to suit his situation. Nor will the fact that it would appear to be opposed to the holy grail that is the Patten report. The most relevant passage from the Patten report is this one (my emphasis): The second point is that the RUC has stricter eligibility criteria than other police services in that relatively minor police records can disqualify a candidate from further consideration. Young people from communities alienated from the police are more likely than others to have had minor run-ins with the police, and those communities are precisely the ones from which more recruits are needed. We emphatically do not suggest that people with serious criminal or terrorist backgrounds should be considered for police service but we do recommend that young people should not be automatically disqualified for relatively minor criminal offences, particularly if they have since had a number of years without further transgressions, and that the criteria on this aspect of eligibility should be the same as those in the rest of the United Kingdom. We also recommend that there should be a procedure for appeal to the Police Ombudsman against disqualification of candidates. There must be no predisposition to exclude candidates from republican backgrounds. I don't know if the presumed Sinn Fein demand for terrorist convictions to be wiped clean is a 'deal breaker'. The Policing Board would collapse, as even the SDLP might consider it a resigning matter, given their hostility to the idea. Unionists certainly won't buy it, even if they do have to accept the inevitability of active republicans joining the PSNI. I see the most likely outcome at this early stage as an opportunity for a classic piece of Blairism - sidestep the problem and clabber your solution in spin. In this case, Blair will seek a quick-fix compromise. It will likely be in the guise of somthing like the neighbourhood policing units which are being rolled out across the rest of the UK. Unionists can hardly complain about a republican agenda, if they're getting the same kind of policing as Yorkshire, can they? Well, they can, but Blair will insist there will be 'safeguards'. (Perhaps a clue to the community policing recruitment criteria regarding previous convictions can be found here (Column 658), in a statement by the previous Secretary of State.) While events may or may not pan out like this, I have a feeling that the jungle of obstacles blocking Sinn Fein's path towards the Policing Board will be cleared by neighbourhood police from nationalist communities. They won't all have the powers of a full officer, but will probably be able to arrest and detain, and issue fixed penalties. The IRA is not able to properly police crimes in the community it is part of - kneecapping never stopped joyriding, and its offer to shoot the killers of Robert McCartney shows just how far removed the IRA was in March from dealing with crime in an democratically acceptable manner. Perhaps the wording of the statement was meant to demonstrate just that. Neither can any republican agency can effectively deal with crimes like rape, where beating or shooting the alleged perpetrator (if they can even be identified) is probably of little comfort to a traumatised victim. Despite this, Sinn Fein does not recommend that victims of sexual assaults talk to the police, if they want to. I suspect that SF would like to be able to, in order to avoid accusations of denying victims justice. Like everywhere else, areas where the IRA exerts control need proper policing (although it would be nice to see it in some loyalist areas right now). Neighbourhood policing, restorative justice and other community-based schemes will be the vehicles towards acceptance of the PSNI - anything one step removed from the State, but still closer to it than at any time in living memory. Unfortunately, the pay-off may be that by effectively setting up another tier of policing at a localised level, we are creating seperate 'Balkanised' community police forces - one for us'uns and one for themmuns. Could the price for policing be a more segregated Northern Ireland? August 29, 2005Blackmen return to Donegal in peace...Before it passed unremarked about, the last of the summer's big Survey of Mass-goersThe University of Ulster is undertaking an independent survey of mass-goers at St. Eugene's Parish in Londonderry to find how they think money should be raised for the controversial Stewardship Trust Fund. The fund, set up by Irish Bishops, helps compensate victims of abuse by Catholic Priests and to fund child protection initiatives. Fr Michael Canny said he was "prepared to adide" by the findings of the survey. What's to love?The "Love Ulster" campaign has got a lot of air, and press, space today.. most notably in the Newsletter - UTV carries the Press Association report.. although the, so far sparse, website seems more concerned with expressing opposition than celebrating. It all combines to create, at least initially, a high profile lobbying campaign.. whether it can continue with that profile may well depend on a lot more openness about who is involved in the campaign. Something that the campaign itself seems opposed to - In keeping with the intention to make the campaign people-led, it will be launched by faces mainly unknown to the public. Pakoras in the ParkThis weekend saw the return of the Mela festival to Belfast. The festival which celebrates Indian culture took place yesterday in Botanic gardens. Mumbai dancers flew in to entertain the crowds and artists from across the world took to the stage from 12 noon. Traditional food was also prepared by chefs. Festival organiser, Nisha Tandon, said she hoped the event would become an annual one for Belfast. She thanked the variety of volunteers from the "the Indian, Chinese and local community". August 28, 2005 Evacuation of New Orleans OrderedAs RTÉ put it - "Mandatory evacuations are underway in the city of New Orleans. The city, with a population of about 1.4 million people, is about two metres below sea level.".. there's much more here, here, and here.. and we're sending out good vibes to those in the area.. Update and to those nearby. Update 2 More links from the Professor One to WatchChannel 4 are running promos for a feature-length history special on Thursday 1st September at 9pm - The Year London Blew up: 1974 - and the opening line on the Channel 4 site certainly sounds interesting - "What happens when a city faces a cell of fanatics with a single goal: to bring the maximum terror to the civilian population?" - that's the IRA cell known as the Balcombe Street gang btw. Even more interestingly, it's a co-production with RTÉ.. which broadcast it in two parts back in March of this year - viewing figures here. The headline on An Phoblacht's review of the March showing on RTÉ perhaps provides the best indicator as to whether it's worth watching "Propaganda posing as history" [scroll down] - definitely worth watching then. The Channel 4 description of the programme is as follows - Told through documentary, drama and first-hand accounts, this feature-length history special is a unique account of the most ruthless IRA bombing campaign ever to hit mainland Britain. Although The Sunday Business Post took a different line in its review of the programme when it was shown on RTÉ, complaining that - The Year London Blew Up was a powerful reminder of a dark and terrible time. But it came nowhere near explaining why or how individuals could attune themselves mentally to leaving a car bomb in a city street, knowing the consequences. The Sunday Business Post also helpfully reminds us that the Balcombe Street gang, whose activities the programme covers - including the murder of Ross McWhirter - were led by Martin O'Connell and included Glasgow-born Hugh Doherty, brother of Sinn Féin vice-president Pat Doherty. They were released temporarily for a 1998 Sinn Féin ard fheis - before being granted early release on licence, under the terms of the Good Friday Agreement. Does Ian know?According to author Clare Asquith, in her book Shadowplay, William Shakespeare was a political rebel who wrote in code - his "plays and poems are a network of crossword puzzle-like clues to his strong Catholic beliefs and his fears for England's future.".. or as this Washington Post review puts it "Papish Plots".. although, personally, I agree with Kiernan Ryan in The Guardian - Embedding the plays in the culture that cradled them can teach us all sorts of invaluable things that enhance our understanding of them. But it's hopeless at explaining why the glovemaker's lad from Stratford still captivates audiences on every continent, while the other dazzling dramatists of his day do not.August 27, 2005 What did Mo stand for..?WRITING in Spiked, Brendan O'Neill casts a critical eye over Mo Mowlam's tenure as Northern Ireland Secretary. Drawing parallels with Robin Cook, who also died recently, he argues that they were figureheads for the 'politics of disgruntlement', "fallen Blairites kicking against the party" after they fell out of favour. He also downplays Mowlam's perceived crucial role in the negotiation of the Good Friday Agreement, where even Mowlam said she felt more like the tea lady than a serious player. O'Neill writes: The obituaries treated Mowlam as if she were someone's (perhaps everyone's) mum rather than a politician. But, in a sense, this was entirely fitting. For all the claims that Mowlam was the anti-Blair, she, like Blair, played on the personal touch. Today, in the absence of political principles and ideology we are left with the empty politics of personality and good character. .... Mowlam, Cook and others were not spearheading an independent challenge against Blairism but rather were fallen Blairites kicking against the party. The response to their tragic deaths - where various politicos and commentators have complained about the dire state of the democratic left and said 'we now know exactly how bad things are' - reveals the paucity of today's critique of New Labour (12). If you want a new 'passionate politics' and an opposition to the Labour government, then a first step would be to look outside of the Labour camp. A place apart, judicially...AFTER the fiasco of loyalist "foot soldiers" escaping jail after they attacked an ice cream van that the UDA wanted protection money from, you might like to compare and contrast court action against similar crimes in Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK. Local rioters rarely (ever?) get more than six months these days, but even after the sentences of some of the Bradford rioters were reduced a couple of years ago, they were still all longer than the average NI sentence - and you'd certainly never hear judges say this in Laganside courthouse. Here's a more recent example of how tribal violence is treated as a crime and not a recreational activity by courts in Great Britain - ten men involved in a violent attack on a Portuguese-run pub after England's defeat in Euro 2004 have been jailed for between eight and 18 months, the Beeb reports. Wouldn't happen here, oh no. Heck, do the clubs here even ban fans who attack other supporters? It's not like you even need an ASBO... Suicide bombs and ballot boxes...THE Hamas militant at the top of Israel's 'Most Wanted' list has released a video in which he issues a statement that bears a striking similarity to another famous soundbite from Danny Morrison in 1981. The BBC reports that Mohammed Deif warned Palestinian officials against ending what he calls the armed struggle, but urges them to resolve internal differences through dialogue. And to the Palestinian Authority he suggests: "We should keep the arms of resistance raised side by side with the political work and we warn against harming this weapon that liberated Gaza. "Let it continue to be active and operational to liberate the rest of our homeland". And, in seeking to justify his own armed struggle, he said: "Without this jihad and this steadfastness, we did not achieve the liberation of the Gaza Strip." It all sounds too familiar... Interesting blogger journo factoid...51% of journalists read blogs regularly. 28% depend on them for material on a daily basis! Blogging may still not be considered journalism (though I'd argue that's a financial constraint more than one dictated by the form), but it's clearly got a (up till now) hidden (and potentially powerful) role in how the news cycle is generated. when the hawthorn foams into streams of blossomIrish writer John McGahern featured heavily in the Radio3 Twenty Minutes programme recently on The Committee On Evil Literature.. understandably.. and, as Sinéad pointed out, he is due to appear on RTÉ's Rattlebag on 1st September. His new book Memoir hasn't fallen foul of the censor.. and, today, there's an extract in The Irish Times[subs req].. with an alternative extract in The Guardian Review [no subs req] August 26, 2005 Mixed messages...DEBORAH McAleese reports that four men under UDA orders who attacked an ice cream vendor who refused to pay 'protection money' escaped custodial sentences. According to Mickey Donnelly, the judge was apparently bound by the constraints of the law (which absolves him to an extent). However, while the four loyalist monkeys are still free, questions must be raised about why the two UDA organ grinders were not facing charges, with Judge Neil McKay stating that "it is most regrettable, for whatever reason, these men were not brought before the court and severely punished for their disgracful behaviour". It's not like the PSNI don't know their identity - after all, the ice cream salesman was an undercover cop. At a time when there is concern in both the unionist and nationalist communities about who really controls the streets here - loyalist terrorists/gangsters or the PSNI - it sends out a very worrying message. What's in a name...NO-ONE seems to know who is responsible for parades, and the Parades Commission and the police appear to have received conflicting legal advice. I rather suspect that, legally, the Pardes Commission has been suckered on this one... The Tele report: The Government has since said there is confusion over the laws and that its legal advice has suggested forms may be legally completed even if the names of individuals were not submitted. However, at a public meeting of the east Belfast District Policing Partnership this week, UUP MLA Michael Copeland asked Chief Superintendent Henry Irvine if the PSNI and Parades Commission received opposing legal advice on the forms. Mr Irvine said there were two sets of legal advice. He said the view taken by the Parades Commission was that the completion of the 11/1 forms with multiple names was not acceptable. He said he had taken guidance from the PSNI legal adviser and that because there was a difference in the two sets of advice, the matter should go to the PPS. He said: "There were different pieces of legal advice, but they were only advice. They do not become guidance until the courts adjudicate." But Mr Copeland countered: "I find it hard to accept that the PSNI ignored their own legal advice, the consequences of that are frightful. "I find myself in the middle of an experiment between two wings of Government who had different views on how a piece of paper should be filled in." Regional rivalry...LORD (Neil) Kinnock, the former Labour Party leader, has warned that tensions between nations are being fostered by fears of a break-up of the United Kingdom. It was reported that he said the devolution of powers at different paces across Britain would lead to misunderstandings and enmity between the nations and the regions. In the debate over whether the Welsh Assembly should get more powers, the double-jobbing Welsh and Northern Ireland Secretary is against a referendum on the issue. Of course, I'm sure Mr Hain has a different position when it comes to the devolution of policing and justice powers to a restored NI Assembly! Kinnock said: "What continues to concern me is not decentralisation of effective administrative and executive power but the fear, and the fear still exists, of the fragmentation of the United Kingdom and the possibility of enmity growing out of it." "Unless there is a general pattern of decentralisation throughout the whole of the United Kingdom, the possibility of tensions, misunderstandings, even antagonisms between the different parts of the United Kingdom, continues." Lisdoonvarna matchmaking festivalSpeed-dating hasn't hit this part of the world (thank goodness) although it has gone techie and has its very own website. Anyone off to Lisdoonvarna this weekend ??? is it true that Irishmen are the most romantic in the world? Something to ponder over the weekend!
Belfast Telegraph Home > News > Features Love is in the air It has been a quiet week at the beef farms on the Burren. An occasional crow calls out over the fairy fort near Ennis, and a harsh Atlantic wind is blowing up at the Cliffs of Moher where two local craftsmen will hammer your name in ancient script on a tiny piece of tin. But all around Lisdoonvarna, the farmers are listening out for a different sound. From today, this small spa town in County Clare is going to be transfigured. The first coaches will roll in, the boats will dock and the planes will roar down the runway at Shannon airport, with a thousand Irish ears attuned to the sounds of their engines. Because tomorrow will bring women, by the coach, plane and boat-load, and they will all be looking for love among the lucky menfolk of Lisdoonvarna. The town's 150-year-old matchmaking festival is the subject of folklore. It inspired Christy Moore to sing about "hairy chests and milk-white thighs", and Brendan Shine to write a song called "Catch Me If You Can". "I'm awful shifty," he said, "for a man of 50. I'm off for the craic, the women and the beer". Things have changed in the world of dating since landowners used to bring their daughters into town and haggle over dowries of cows. Speed-dating and chat rooms have replaced the annual ceilidh for maids looking for a partner. But Lisdoonvarna's matchmaker, Willie Daly, is still doing things the traditional way. "I've been a matchmaker for close on 40 years now," he says. "My father and grandfather had done it before me, and I wasn't planning on doing it, but I could see there was a need for it in the area." The lot of men has not been an easy one of late. "Women in the last 20 years have become considerably more independent. Psychologically, their mind dwells in other places. The grass is always greener. Women travel to the cities and men stay at home. It is very difficult for them." This year, though, the bachelors can afford to be optimistic. "There has been quite a lot of interest in Irish men from women in eastern countries: Thailand, the Philippines and the like," says Daly. "These are sensitive women and very, very beautiful. They do make marvellous wives." He does not mean to be controversial but Willie Daly is a champion of the Irish male. "These women were trained from the day they were born to totally love a man. When he gets up in the morning they would be happy to put his shoes on for him. But Irish girls with careers can buy their own homes and some feel they don't need a man at all." He is also an admirer of the colleen, of course: "Irish girls are very winsome and very beautiful, and they've got a lovely charm," he insists with a faraway look in his eye. But his latest successes have been with Asian women. "Three of them have married fellas around here and people have realised these girls have such a very nice, gentle, sweet nature. Now we have had lots of bachelors actually coming forward and specifically asking for Asian girls." Much else has changed since Daly matched his first couple. He has been invited to weddings and christenings, and disinvited from others because the couple don't want everyone to know how they met. When he started, "nearly 100%" of the people on his books were young single men and women, with a few people who had buried a spouse. "There are much more separated and widowed now," he observes. "Nearly a third each way." The Americans, too, have come to Lisdoonvarna. "American women get on very well with Irish men. Many of them might have been married a couple of times, well a few times, and they're looking for a bit of a character. They'll be well-off financially and they seem to fall in love very quickly. English women get on very well here, too. They might have to drink a few extra drinks to get into the Irish ways, but if you don't, well you might as well not come, eh?" Daly is sure that Irish men are "the most romantic in the world". He is, himself, a charmer. With snow-white hair and forget-me-not eyes, he gives the impression he could butter up three women at once and still have time to write a book on the subject. But his efforts are entirely on behalf of his clients. "A woman came last year who had only one leg, and she said she'd been to lots of dances and nobody had even asked her to dance," he says, shaking his head. "By the end of the festival, she had four proposals of marriage." He later admits that one of the betrothed had to be run to ground in another pub, after leaving his new sweetheart with the information that he had a cow to calf back at the farm, and slipping next door for a post-engagement pint of Guinness. There are some locals who suspect that the young folk are hijacking the festival, using it as an excuse for drinking in the street with not a thought for marriage or a long-term, mutually satisfactory, match. "There are four sisters who come to the festival every year from England," says Pat O'Connor, who lives in Limerick. "They're all married. But then I have a cousin in Cork who's in her 40s and she's not married. She'll be coming again. I think she might find someone this time." They believe in magic around here. That's why they diverted the dual carriageway from the airport to avoid disturbing the fairy fort. It is why they have founded a pub dedicated to Biddy Early, a local witch who was run out of town for putting a curse on the entire hurling team. And maybe it is why they claim Guinness is an aphrodisiac, an aid to fertility and a cure for insomnia, too. Whatever, it certainly keeps them coming back. As well as the happy convergence of Ireland and eastern Asia, the festival has received another unexpected fillip in recent years. "Some of the men who were coming in the 60s were saying they were getting too old for it all," explains Mr Daly. "And then they made this Viagra, and they're all back again. A couple of years ago there was a man from the village selling blue Smarties to the men. And the men were coming back saying: 'This Viagra is the best, you'd better sell me some more.' He bought all the Smarties they had, because you only get one or two blue ones in each packet, you see. It was all right because I have lots of grandchildren and they all lived on Smarties for the rest of that summer." Lisdoonvarna is moving with the times. A Lisdoonvarna matchmaking festival web-site, matchmakerireland.com, even offers speed-dating to modern farmers. It calls it "the latest craze" with "the possibility of meeting 50 dates for three minutes!" But Daly still does things the old-fashioned way. "My matchmaking business is better than ever," he confirms. "There is a lot of madness out there and people can't be themselves too easily. Girls want to be introduced to somebody to know he's an OK kind of fella and he's not married." With modern computer dating, he says, women have to be a bit careful. "I charge a fee to the men and very little to the women. That helps to get rid of the messers." And, it is true, the matchmaker's book is bulging with hopeful singles. "Get the pretty ones at the top," he says as he poses in the window of The Matchmaker pub for a photograph, the Polaroids spilling out from the pages of names and particulars. To bring his service up to date, Daly has introduced one new innovation: horseback "love trails" around the rocky local land they call the Burren. He runs them with his daughter Marie, and a mass of grandchildren scamper around the horses and beguile the American ladies who swear they have only come to admire the view. "You can go for three days or for six days on the love trails, and 'tis a very romantic landscape," says Daly, wistfully. "If there is love in you, you can guarantee Lisdoonvarna will ignite it." Gerry Fitt 1926-2005Sadly today we mark the passing of one of Northern Ireland's more substantial figures. PSNI open minds or eyes wide shut?After comments from Deputy Chief Constable Paul Leighton that a series of sectarian attacks in Ahoghill may be down to bad neighbours rather than sectarianism, the difficulty the PSNI have in admitting 15yr old Thomas Devlin's murder was sectarian, PSNI Supt Terry Shelvin getting ‘fed up’ over criticism and wasting his resources dealing (or not) with the attacks, another PSNI officer, Paul Bailey, district commander for Moyle, has joined the PSNI in Antrim finding difficulty defining (or admitting) what is a sectarian attack. In this instance Mr Bailey is keeping an open mind on if an attack outside Ballymoney was sectarian, the petrol bomb and ‘Taigs Out’ graffiti don’t seem to have helped him make his mind up. Sinn Féin MLA Philip McGuigan has raised criticisms, "It is becoming very clear to nationalists that there is a tolerance of unionist paramilitary violence amongst senior figures within the PSNI. There can be no other explanation for their failure to tackle this campaign or at the very least publicly acknowledge that it is happening at all." Past the 50 million mark (England's population that is)In today's Independent there is what some of us might regard as a fitting, if belated, tribute to Malthus' theory of population control. In the 1830's the population of the larger island to the East, taken as a whole, was 10 millions. That of its smaller neighbour was 8. It's interesting to speculate what the combined population of both parts of the island of Ireland would have been if there hadn't been immigration due to the famine ? Population of England exceeds 50 million for the first time The population of England has risen above 50 million for the first time, according to figures from the Office for National Statistics. Complementary mediaIn today's Irish Examiner's Ronan Mullen has spotted Slugger friend Sheila's blog and, in particular, a great post on the changing face of Dublin, and Ireland - Road Works Ahead - from where he goes on to discuss Rip Off Ireland. There's a slight breach of etiquette however - he neglects to provide a link to the post, or blog, he's referring to. Ah well, at least it's an acknowledgement that blogs and the wider media can complement each other and refer back to each other, as Sheila does today - with a link. And the uncool bar he avoids naming? The Ice Bar at the Four Seasons Hotel in Dublin. August 25, 2005 Flagging up another problem...A SENIOR cop lays into a government department for refusing to help remove flags in Limavady. Once again, the Department of Regional Development takes the 'play safe, do nothing' approach that even a more pro-active PSNI seems to be slowly moving away from these days. The Tele reported: The DRD said that they had arranged a meeting with the Limavady police chief for next week. A spokeswoman said: "Roads Service policy is where complaints are received and there is no danger to road users, to gauge community reaction to determine the likely success of any action that might be taken. "This is generally done through consultation with local councillors, other public representatives and the PSNI." The PSNI Divisional Commander for Limavady pointed out a problem in the system that was brushed under the carpet a while ago, in the hope that no-one would notice - the police are powerless to use anti-terror legislation to remove non-paramilitary flags. So much for a joined-up approach! Ultimate chav gets screwed by millie...ENGLISH uberspide, lottery winner and UDA supporter Michael Carroll gets the full 'kiss and tell' treatment from his 17-year-old ex-girlfriend in today's Sun. The King of Chavs' wife is now keeping herself to herself in Belfast, and won't let him see his daughter. It's a sordid tale of sex, drugs and ASBOs, but you can only read it all if you bought the paper today. Bah! YR Sauce coming back to a store near you, soon!Well, it's good news from Chivers Managing Director Liam O'Rourke, who's written to Slugger explaining the current hiatus in the 'food chain' in Northern Ireland. Pending a new distribution deal covering NI and Britain, you should be able to ask your local shop to order it! From Liam O'Rourke The situation re YR is that we have the product in wide distribution here in ROI it is listed in every major store and most minor stores also. We purchased YR from Unilever in 2002 as part of Gooodalls. We have been seeking a good reliable Distributor for the Brand in the UK and NI so far without success,though we believe we are close !! It is a brand we believe in and one which we would like to "fire up". We will do this when we get a strong distribution position in NI and UK. At present we support the brand in the Republic with promotional activity and it is as popular as ever here. Rumours of its death are greatly exaggerated in the case of ROI. I accept that it is difficult to get north of the border and impossible to get in GB. It is available as you know through Sawyers but also if you and others were to ask your local stores whoever they may be to stock it and contact us we will make every effort to supply as quickly as possible. I believe that occasionally through such requests by consumers it is stocked by Musgrave SuperValu stores in NI. Lollipops To Be Dropped From The PramOn the same day that it emerges that Northern Irish students are, once again, outperforming their counterparts in England and Wales in GCSE exams, it has also been reported that there will be controversial cuts in crossing patrol services at schools in Northern Ireland. The cuts come as the Education Boards are struggling to make ends meet. Trade union NIPSA has revealed that many lollipop staff may be forced to consider quitting their posts because of the dramatic impact new reduced hours are having on their income. The BELB threw out plans to reduce dozens of lollipop patrols following the successful “Save the Lollipop Service” campaign by the Belfast Telegraph. It seems that the September return to school will not be a happy one for many of the staff affected by the cuts. Politicians need to tell like it is...BIg Ulsterman is less than impressed with the condemnation from Ian Paisley over recent violence towards some of his North Antrim constitency. UUP & Multiculturalism: for or against?The UUP has an interesting and expansive line on Northern Ireland as a multicultural society. There's some evidence that it is popular with the younger elements in the party. But what worries the blogger over at About EU is the party's call to restrict the number of places given to overseas students in UK universities. Along with Sinn Fein's Davy Hyland's remarks, it begs the question as to how far any of the local parties have got in thinking through emergent (non constitutional) issues. War and Peace and War?A fascinating article in the Guardian's Life section today - let down, unfortunately, by an over-emphasis on current events at the end - about the "We do not really study [historical] causes, but what people at the time thought were the causes. And our aim in retrieving their thoughts is not so much to explain how things happened as to understand how they seemed to have happened." JoBlog joins the NI Blogosphere...Despite appearances, I'm not back to full blogging until next week. The NI blogosphere is growing all the time. The latest to join in the fun is Slugger regular Jo. Here she digs into Toby Harden's Bandit Country. You couldn’t make it up. So why would APNI?Alliance Cllr Maire Hendron claimed Sinn Féin lied about trouble in East Belfast on Monday. UUP MLA Michael Copeland has confirmed the Sinn Féin report saying they met that night to defuse tensions. Maybe Cllr Hendron was tucked up in bed? Can Nationalism and social justice mix?Intertesting piece from Alan Bairner, a Scottish academic writer on sport and politics in, who reflects on the sometimes uncomfortable mix of national and social politics, whilst sitting with the Irish contingent of cricket supporters at the first Ashes test in Lords earlier this year. The saying "You can choose your friends but not your family" applies equally well to your compatriots. In the case of Ireland, it was for this very reason that James Connolly wrote in Shan Van Vocht (1897): "As a socialist I am prepared to do all one man can do to achieve for our motherland her rightful heritage — independence; but if you ask me to abate one jot or title on the claims of social justice in order to conciliate the privileged classes then I must decline." Connolly recognised that national self-determination can be a first step towards social justice but there are always enemies closer to home. I'm also indebted to him for a great Scots quote: "Here's tae us. Wha's like us? Gey few and they're a' deid!". Time to call the paramilitary bluff?Lindy McDowell certainly doesn't pussyfoot around in her suggestion as to what to do about the latest outburst of Loyalist violence. But that's what she accuses the government of doing. She argues that the people behind the orchestration of violence and intimidation are not known to the public, but are to the security forces: ...the only thing these men are loyal to are themselves - to their own hip pockets, their own vanity, their own position. They leach off the community from which they come. And in the name of that community they order acts of yellow barbarity that shame the very name "loyalist." From the so-called low-level acts of cowardly intimidation like daubing obscenities on a chapel door, through driving innocent people from their homes, right through to the murder of innocent Catholics. And the most shocking, sickening aspect of all this? It's been going on for years and years and years. And there seems to be no end of it in sight. For quite simply, there appears to be no-one in authority with the will to stop it. She suggests the authorities should simply move in and arrest them. And she ventures a few guesses on why it's not happened thus far: If the Government were to move against these organisations they could, in fact, count on massive support from within that community. The Government's problem is about being seen to move unilaterally against one set of terrorist leaders. In other words, if they scoop the loyalists, might they not come under pressure to scoop the republicans? Is that where the problem lies? The new "us'uns"...REPUBLICANS have been exploring the possibility of tapping into the growing foreign worker vote in order to strengthen their political position, the News Letter has reported. Sinn Fein MLA for Newry and Armagh, Davy Hyland, said: "There certainly are large numbers of them here in Newry. I passed a house recently where about 50 were having a party and, as they are mostly Catholic, they are more sympathetic to the nationalist outlook." Who says republicans can't be prejudiced?! August 24, 2005 Bring in the Clowns – At Least In MoyleYes, for once, I am not making a joke about politicians being clowns. Moyle Council is set to allow circuses to return to council land after a blanket ban on all circuses with performing animals, which has been in place since the 1990s, has been overturned.. A motion, proposed by Sinn Fein councillor Oliver McMullan has been passed in recognition of tighter controls on animal welfare. As before, circuses will only be allowed to work on council land if they meet certain criteria. Hopefully this is a move that will be followed by similar actions from other local councils, as I believe the councils seem unaware of the damage they are actually causing animals who are forced to stay in less comfortable conditions on non council land. *slurp* *slurp*Now, where was I? *slurp* Oh yes.. The Belfast Telegraph focuses, just about [or is that you? - Ed], on the Northern Ireland aspect of a recent report on the drinking habits of the UK and other European citizens. It seems that drinking wine at home is on the increase *slurp* According to unnamed drinks industry experts, "the demise of the Troubles has fuelled a boom in wine consumption".. hmm.. AND they helpfully reference a Belfast-based online store, Direct Wine Shipments.. although, I have to shay *slurp* that the on-line shtock sheems a little reshtricted compared to the major competition *hic* "Such a dramatisation of lavatory necessities is offensive"As I previously noted Peter Hall has a new production of Waiting for Godot, at the Theatre Royal, Bath, to celebrate the 50th Anniversary of the first English production of the play.. which, at the age of 24, he was also responsible for. In today's Guardian he looks back fondly to that production, while generously reviewing his new production. Heh. And congratulates the audiences, beyond the preview that is, for their less than reverential approach to the timeless masterpiece. But he's not a happy man, as The Independent also reported earlier this month. Hall wanted to bring the show to London in September only to have that idea vetoed by London's Barbican Centre and the Gate Theatre in Dublin, who have the rights to all Beckett plays ahead of the Beckett Centenary celebration planned for April 2006. He also, perhaps unfairly, refers back to the original production's problems with the Lord Chamberlain's blue pencil - an interesting comparison to the previously noted Committee on Evil Literature - and the complaints of the more genteel members of the earlier audiences - When in 1955 the play transferred to the Criterion (a public theatre governed by the licensing authorities), the lord chamberlain - censor of the day - busily exercised his blue pencil. Beckett was amazed that in England, the cradle of free speech, the theatre - unlike books or broadcasting or film - was heavily censored by the government. If Beckett was amazed then.. Hall suggests his reaction to the current situation would be somewhat similar - At a time when Sam should be universally celebrated as his centenary approaches, they have all the rights in the plays for their own big Beckett centenary festival in April next year and insist on this moratorium. So no one else may celebrate Sam's life and work in London from next week onwards. Sam would have found such a situation very whimsical. McDowell: Colombia three have implications for SFMichael McDowell puts the blame for the escape and re-appearance of the Colombian Three on the Army Council of the IRA. He notes that in light of recent press reports this may have been known to includes high level members of Sinn Fein. The minister added: "Their presence [the Colombia Three] raises very, very serious questions for the Provo movement and for the people who were in charge of that movement at the time that they were sent there using false identities." On the men`s trip to Colombia, he said: "As far as I am concerned it can only have been done, because it was so fraught with difficulty and risk, with the collusion of the top management of the Provisional movement, and I am talking now about the Army Council." What's happened to Goodalls YR sauce?I spent some of last week scouring supermarkets and convenience stores for a couple of bottles of Goodalls good ole Yorkshire Relish and a few more of the YR sauce. None of the outlets I tried in Belfast from M&S to Curley's had it. What's the story? Dallat condemns extreme websitesSDLP East Londonderry MLA John Dallat has called for tighter controls of websites that promote paramilitaries on the net. Relax, Slugger is not amongst them. But it appears John's been walking on the darker side of the net in recent times. It also appears that the producers of one of the sites has already made good its reply. Update: It looks like PA have been doing some further digging on this issue. Stay with us for further developments. From John Dallat: Loyalist FM is a radio station broadcasting on the net. It claims on its website to be only about loyalist culture. But just listen to it for a few minutes and you will find out that it glorifies loyalist paramilitaries and their bloody violence. Some of the lyrics of songs broadcast include: ‘U stands for Ulster And that’s the way it’ll stay FF for Freedom Fighter So fuck the IRA’ And - All Protestants must fight for Ulster’s freedom… Let’s go up the Falls Road.’ And - “Give my gun To all my sons Let them fight as I have done… 10,000 men will fight and die We are men of the UDA.” And - “Oh my father said to me I must join the YCV With a rifle or a pistol in my hand. Though I am 16 years old In the Volunteers I’ll engage Like our fathers did so many years ago.” Given the countless massacres that loyalist paramilitaries have been involved in, this is obviously just about incitement to hatred and lawlessness. That is why I am referring this website to the police. If broadcasting this kind of hate is not already illegal, it should be made illegal. I had already made this point to Lord Rooker last week before he went on holidays but still the station broadcasts. It is all the more shocking to find that people are willing to be associated with this website. In fact, it is publicly sponsored by the Bentley Club in Knocklaughrim Co Derry. Paramilitaries have brought endless suffering to the people of the North and it is sickening that anybody would sponsor a website that openly glorifies them. There are equally shocking republican websites. For example, www.fiannaeireann.com openly encourages recruitment to the youth wing of Continuity IRA. This is about turning them into child soldiers. It is about child abuse. It is amazing that nothing is done to shut this website down. If it were about other forms of child abuse, such as sex abuse, every effort would rightly be made to close it. Yet nothing appears to be done to stop the recruitment of child soldiers and encouraging them into a life of violence and danger. Paramilitaries on both sides have brought endless suffering to thousands on this island. It is deeply worrying that the net is being used not just to glorify them, but to perpetuate this misery into the future. When the law is dragged into disrepute...Interesting and thoughtful analysis from Eric Waugh, which argues that the pragmatic response of successive British government in dealing with paramilitaries, both during and after the conflict, has left it morally if not legally compromised in dealing with the last vestiges of Northern Ireland's long internecine war. The way is now cleared for the working out of a scene deeply traditional in Irish history: for when one grouping dares to seek a modus vivendi with the old enemy, as Redmond did over Home Rule in 1912 and as Collins did over the treaty of 1921, as O'Neill attempted in 1965 and Faulkner in 1973, they tend to be outflanked by shriller voices seeking to seize the abandoned ground. Informing these voices is a single quantity; and that quantity is political violence - or the threat of it. Waugh argues that the root of the problem the government faces in tackling the current Loyalist feud lies deep within the history of the current troubles: Faced with the sort of nascent revolution that surfaced in Northern Ireland in the late 1960s, Government had two choices: to confront it with matching force or to seek to police it by a mixture of cajolery, bribery and undercover intrigue. Of course the latter was the option chosen. Option one would have enforced the law; but it would also have threatened civil war and major international difficulty. Such was not to be entertained. The flaw lay in the consequent absence of law under option two. Violence, far from being confronted, was rewarded. The most heinous killers were released. He goes on to argue that the government itself was compromised in it's use of double agents in the Loyalist paramilitaries. He sees it's legacy in the widely percieved inaction of the police in several current scenarios: The community at large is left with the violent legacy, which includes the revolting, if pathetic, thuggery in Ahoghill. There, as elsewhere, the law is treated with contempt. On the border, security is wound down while extortion and the traffic in smuggled narcotics, which finances the terrorists, waxes beyond control. So the dilemma of the Government is that, of itself, it has destroyed the notion upon which good order subsists; and that notion is that lawlessness brings vengeance. Necessary journalism of the tabloidsMost of polite society in Northern Ireland turns up its collective nose at the tabloid reporting of papers like the Sunday World. However, Brian Wilson writing in the Scotland on Sunday sees the latest campaign against the paper as testimony to its constant focus on the day to day realities of paramilitary life in the largely working class areas of Northern Ireland. We all want to see peace prevail in Northern Ireland. But there is a danger that a price of declaring peace has been to turn a blind eye to very nasty things that continue to happen. The paramilitary organisations on both sides have long since been political fronts for gangsterism and racketeering. All of that cannot simply be swept under the carpet in the name of peace. Love thy neighbour?Latest outburst by evangelical preacher Pat Robertson vis a vis Venezuela President Hugo Chavez seems a little 'unchristian' or is it just the new othordoxy? Assassinate Chavez, Pat Robertson tells a stunned America Pat Robertson, one of the most influential Christian evangelists in the United States, has sparked controversy by calling for the assassination of the left-wing leader of Venezuela.
Reputations up for debateThanks to Ciarán I'll be trying to find a few free hours over the next couple of days.. but, as he says, this is really interesting stuff. Reputations, an RTE Radio series examining the complexities of the history of Ireland through contrasting attitudes to some of the controversial figures who framed it. RTE have already archived the programmes on Pearse, Parnell, O'Connell, Wolf Tone and Hugh O'Neill, with Diarmuid MacMurrough up for discussion next week. Even better, RTE have made available extended versions of each programme.. in the case of Parnell that's an extra 20-odd minutes of contributions from historians Roy Foster and Paul Bew. The Kit.. and the KaboodleSpotted by Sheila. Some wise words on blogging by Joel Achenbach in the Washington Post - America [and everywhere else - Ed], it turns out, is full of smart, clever, creative people who happen to have no interest in working and whose employers have unwisely given them Internet access. Thus every day, on my blog, these strangers show up, just to shoot the breeze, flirt, kvetch, veer off topic and, most of all, pay zero attention to what I have written. Oh.. and as Joel also says - And let me just add, purely for the sake of Google: sex, alien abduction, Oprah, Tom Cruise, Lindsay Lohan, jumbo hooters the size of watermelons, Dick Cheney, Mark of the Beast, Armageddon, free money. *Ahem* Our Scots-Irish Presbyterian heritage celebrated...IT'S been a good week for rednecks, even if some of us lost the plot. There was the premiere of the Dukes of Hazzard last night, peace in Lagan Valley with Alabama 3 last Friday and the spectacular finale to mark the end of Hunter S Thompson's life - as his suicidal ashes were scattered over Aspen, Colorado by a fist sculpture/cannon paid for by Johnny Depp at the weekend. Will Bloggers inherit the Gonzo? August 22, 2005 Politics undermining policing progressThe BBC report of the announcement today that 2 of the 8 PSNI stations, the future of which the public was being consulted on, are to remain open exemplifies the problems still faced by policing here. From the initial recommendation by Hugh Orde that they should close, to the process of a public consultation, and the continued resistance to movement on this issue by, in this example, the DUP MLA Arlene Foster - "I remain gravely concerned about the closure of other stations," she said. It's a resistance echoed by the, frankly, far more sinister comments of the Sinn Féin Member of Parliament Michelle Gildernew.. who equates police stations to spy bases within communities - "The majority of nationalists do not want these spy bases in their communities." and both are unchallenged by the acceptance of the compromise by the SDLP MLA Alex Atwood - "This is the right balance." All this combines to re-inforce the view of policing as just another political bargaining chip - rather than a required public service to counter criminal activity, being deployed in the most effective manner possible. Btw, the elevation of the ubiquitous community representatives to the status of a semi-official police force can be seen to be yet another example of the, NIO endorsed, increasing, not decreasing, politicisation of policing. Unity found in blaming policeAfter the rioting in Belfast on Saturday night a common cause was forged between Sinn Féin's Deborah Devenny, "The PSNI have once again demonstrated their unwillingness to deal with loyalist thugs intent upon intimidating the people of this area.", and the UUP's Michael Copeland, "Apparent police unwillingness to heed my warnings and pre-empt this situation raises serious questions as to how they are handling this very real problem." - Police criticised after riot - UTV report - of course that criticism didn't do anything to stop more rioting in Belfast last night when, as RTE reported, "Police brought the situation under control shortly after midnight." But will it be worth going to see?The Belfast Telegraph reports, twice, that the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Investment have announced that over 200 submissions have been received in the competition to design the new Giant's Causeway Visitors' Centre. Although as today's DETI statement points out, they are now running a competition to find an exhibition and interpretative designer who "will be required to collaborate with the winning architect to deliver an integrated design solution for the building." Apart from the obvious concern of introducing a new designer to collaborate with the winning architect.. I'm disappointed, to say the least, that the opportunity hasn't been taken to open up the decision beyond the narrow confines of the "international panel of experts under the auspices of the Union of International Architects".. not to mention the selection panel[?] for the exhibition and interpretative designer. Here's an idea.. let the panel of experts pick a short list for the planned Centre from the submissions.. and make the designs available for viewing by the public.. either physically or online.. and get a bit of public reaction before committing to taking it further.. so far, apart from the multi-media downloads avaiable on the DETI website, and some info on the Giant's Causeway on the Environment and Heritage website here, there doesn't seem to be any indication of encouraging public involvement.. beyond the final unveiling that is. Considering that just over 200 firms, from the 480 who had registered for the competition, submitting plans for the Centre - estimated cost of the new facilities £14million - coming up with a short-list of equally valid and impressive designs shouldn't be too difficult. That's assuming the DETI have thought about the need to enthuse the public about this project. Ed JoyceIrish Times profile on Irishman starring across water and seeking to play for England Holiday advice for undercover twitchers...IT'S not just the Colombian government that wants IRA members extradited - now the Germans are getting in on the act too. PA reported that Scotland Yard was involved in the arrest of alleged Osnabruck bomber Leonard 'Bap' Hardy in Spain. Helpfully, Sinn Fein have informed us that the suspect had been living openly in Ireland for years (tut tut, Bertie). So no more overseas birdwatching trips for the C3 then - but perhaps the Hardy case presents an unforeseen problem... If 'On the Run' IRA suspects are allowed home as part of the political deal to restore devolution, then that is a deal between the British Government, the Provos and the Irish Government. So what happens if other governments that have legal treaties with Ireland come knocking on the Dail doors, seeking the extradition of IRA suspects for 'international terrorism' or whatever? To be honest, I can't think of another example outside Germany at the moment. But unionists might argue that the UK's amnesty for IRA fugitves and the German extradition case illustrate how far Britain and Ireland have been prepared to move to tie up republican loose ends (which I suppose is a bit of a compliment to SF's negotiating skills). How would Londoners have reacted if the Italisn government had refused to extradite a man wanted in connection with the failed bomb attacks of 21 July? And isn't it strangely coincidental that Scotland Yard were involved in all this, at this particular time? You'd almost get the impression that someone was pissed off over the Three Amigos making their own way home...! August 21, 2005Telling it like it isTelevision lets a lot of tragedy into our homes, it rarely follows up. The BBC revisited some drug addicted children and found this story. Farewell PDN...Newton Emerson with his farewell to the Internet, or at least the Portadown focused part of it. Love it or hate it, the PDN resides on the blogroll of many bloggers far and wide. Portadown's loss will be our future gain, as he seeks to push his energies into a deeper journalistic furrow. Go Newt! Let us have your memories of NI's No 1 Satirical site. Thanks to Alan for the heads up! One to watch...THE final of the Northern Ireland Trophy - the first major (if non-ranking) tournament here for 18 years is just starting on Eurosport. It was certainly a memorable tournament for world amateur champion, 19-year-old Mark Allen from Antrim, who IIRC won his first seven frames as a professional last week, defeating two former world champions, John Higgins and Steve Davis, who he whitewashed. Pity BBC NI or UTV didn't see the potential in televising a local rising star in his first pro tournament... Fianna Fáil meltdownPrivate polling carried out by Fianna Fáil and covered in the Sunday Tribune (not online) show the party is predicting an electoral meltdown and a spell in opposition. They have also found; ‘strong support in certain areas for Sinn Féin’Highlights below Thanks to Ivan for his help. Sunday Tribune (front page) Sun 21 August - extracts Private polls predict election disaster for Fianna Fáil. Sunday reading...THE loyalist threat to newsagents selling the Sunday World - a tabloid newspaper famous for exposing and ridiculing paramilitary groups - is an attack on freedom of speech. Yet the response from the Government to this situation today is in marked contrast to the way in which Mo Mowlam showed her solidarity with the paper when its offices were firebombed a few years ago. Sadly, all the NIO tea and sympathy in the world won't change the fact that no-one has been prosecuted for SW journalist Marty O'Hagan's murder, and the threat is all too real, as arson is regarded as a serious option by the UDA today. Scotland on Sunday reports: In 1999, the Sunday World offices in Belfast were fire-bombed. The next day, Mo Mowlam visited the scene. She talked to the staff, thanked them for the necessary and courageous work they were doing and subsequently wrote to them individually. It is impossible not to contrast that response with the almost total official silence that has greeted the current campaign against the paper. You've come a long way, baby...STUART Emmrish, editor of the Travel section of the New York Times, returns to find a very different Belfast from the one he remembers seeing in the late 80s. Apart from his disappointment at the empty city centre in the evening, he writes that "the "new" Belfast - the Belfast of outsized ambitions, and perhaps unrealistic expectations - clearly had far to go. But it had already come an awfully long way." The Observer also takes a look at the changing face of Belfast today. Spidewatch...SOME honest opinions on the underclass situation in Lisburn, Belfast, and, of course, Strabane, the third worst place to live in the UK, according to Channel 4. Remember to have a search on the Chavtown site to get an update on the spide situation in your neighbourhood. Slane and sleeping pills...CELEBRITY rumour blog The Superficial reports Eminem's publicist saying the rapper quit his European tour, which included Slane, because he's addicted to sleeping tablets. Some wonderful put-downs on the site too: I've lost all respect for his misogyny and gay bashing now. Never again can I look at a woman or a homosexual and think "I hate you because Eminem told me to." Now you know why Eminem ain't playing Ireland. Allegedly. August 20, 2005 Terry is 'fed up'PSNI Supt Terry Shevlin is ‘fed up’ and worried over the sectarian attacks in Ahoghill, though sectarianism has been disputed previously by senior PSNI officers. ‘Fed up' at criticism over distributing fire blankets instead of arresting and worried the unsuccessful allocation of officers may affect crime statistics elsewhere in Ballymena. (think of the shopkeepers and takings?) Happy Birthday PhilLots of coverage of the unveiling of the life-sized bronze sculpture of Thin Lizzy frontman, and one of Dublin's greatest ever rock stars, Phil Lynott on Harry Street in Dublin yesterday.. ahead of tonight's tribute concert at the Point Theatre on what would have been his 56th birthday. RTE report, BBC here and the Irish Times - who claim 5000 fans turned out to watch the unveiling by his mother, Philomena Lynott - some great photos at Yahoo News here, here and especially here, via Blabbermouth.net.. and there's an RTE Rattlebag special on the life and musical career of Phil Parris Lynott online here [RealPlayer sound file]. Happy Birthday Phil. August 19, 2005 Licensed to kill..?THE WILL to take on the UVF has been sapped from the top, writes Newton Emerson in yesterday's Irish News. The UVF, which claims that its feud rival - the LVF - is riddled with informers who are protected by the State, would appear to have a similar issue with protected agents. Some of it is laughably obvious - the block on the publication of the coroner’s report into the murder of David McIlwaine on security grounds, as Emerson writes, is legal code for saying that the killer was a tout. Why indeed has there never been a conviction for the 30 UVF murders carried out since its 1994 'ceasefire'? It would be unfair not to note that there have also been many odd instances of alleged LVF members facing serious charges in court, only for those charges to be mysteriously dropped by the DPP without explanation. The idea of informers and agents is to garner information to save lives. But because useful informers are sometimes up to their necks in it or career criminals - and yet are protected by the State - it can lead to the situation we have in Belfast today - loyalist Stakeknives. At what point does the information provided by a covert source no longer outweigh the level of terrorist or criminal activity he is engaged in? What should the State's response be when a source may be causing more lives to be lost than saved? Is it really in the public interest that the State protects career criminals and multiple murderers? The spectre of hundreds of UVF supporters recently occupying an east Belfast estate while the PSNI stood and watched - ironically, opposite the police training college - makes you wonder what lesson the post-Patten recruits will really learn about who really runs the streets, and what the Government regards as an acceptable level of loyalist violence and intimidation. David Ervine recently admitted that the PUP has no power to intervene and stop the loyalist feud. You might think that with no political restraint on the UVF whatsoever, that it might be the right time for the Government to make a move and treat the situation more seriously than it currently is doing. It might well be convenient for some if certain loyalists took a few secrets to their grave, but the problem for the rest of us is that uninvolved people get caught in the crossfire causing families unbearable misery. Why is the freedom of a UVF serial killer more important to the State than the lives of his 13 victims? Who exactly is in charge around here? From yesterday's Irish News: Will to prosecute UVF has been sapped from the top The PSNI is sitting on a bomb and the clock is ticking. Before this year is out the police ombudsman will publish a report into the 1997 murder of Raymond McCord jnr. The initial findings, which were widely leaked two years ago, suggest that an informer in the Mount Vernon UVF has murdered at least 13 people since his recruitment in 1993. Special Branch is alleged to have covered up each case. The list of victims is mostly Protestant but includes the all too familiar roll-call of randomly selected Catholics plus the clearly psychotic butchering of Portadown teenagers Andrew Robb and David McIlwaine. When the report breaks the fall-out will be spectacular. British Irish Rights Watch, which has already presented its own confidential findings to the American, British and Irish governments, says the case is: “As bad as it gets.” At least one more high-ranking UVF informer is likely to be exposed but the harshest glare will fall on those in authority who have humoured the phantom of political loyalism without any regard for human life. This is another all too familiar roll-call. Successive secretaries of state and security ministers – up to and including the present incumbents – have persistently refused to review the UVF ‘ceasefire’ despite 30 murders since 1994. Nobody has been convicted for any of those murders, making it absurdly obvious that both the police and the Prosecution Service are under political instruction. The Northern Ireland Office refused extra funding for the ombudsman’s inquiry, delaying it by two years, during which eight of the 30 murders were committed. The additional funding requested was £5 million – roughly what the children’s commissioner has cost over the same period. The chief constable blocked publication of the coroner’s report into the murder of David McIlwaine on security grounds, a move that can only have been made to protect an informer. Everyone involved in these decisions will shortly have to explain them in terms of a preventable death toll exceeding that of the Omagh bomb. It is perfectly possible to justify the use of dangerous informers and it is far too easy to criticise the horrendous compromises necessary when only evil people can provide good information. Shortly after his recruitment the Mount Vernon informer is thought to have led police to a UVF weapons dump and doubtless supplied further useful intelligence. Might he have saved lives overall? Former Special Branch detective Johnston Brown – who put Johnny Adair away only to see Mo Mowlam release him – definitely doesn’t think so. Speaking about the case on UTV two years ago, Mr Brown said: “Could we have put the majority of the Mount Vernon UVF in jail in 1997, 1998, 1999? Absolutely. Lives would have been saved time and time again. There appeared to be no will to prosecute certain individuals.” Given the attempts at every level to frustrate Nuala O’Loan’s inquiry it seems that the will to prosecute the UVF has been sapped from the top. The great and the good of amoral peace processing – Number 10 policy advisor Jonathan Powell springs especially to mind – remain determined to pursue identical policies towards republicans and loyalists although it has been plain for years that loyalists are not responding. No doubt Number 10 blames working-class Protestants for not supporting David Ervine as instructed. No doubt too this makes the predominantly working class Protestant body count easier to bear. But only for a little while longer. As the UVF runs increasingly amok every unpunished outrage will only serve to underscore that looming report. Excuses that never washed in the first place will finally be hung out to dry. What are informers for if their information is never used? Why are prosecutions withheld for lack of evidence when informers can turn Queen’s evidence – and the law was changed after Omagh to make a senior police officer’s testimony sufficient evidence regardless? How many loyalist murders did the NIO think were worth one loyalist MLA? Was it more than 30, perhaps? How many loyalist murders did it think were worth a two-year breather? More than eight, apparently. As the convenient flag of the Mount Vernon UVF now rises above the typically elusive killers of 15-year-old Thomas Devlin, the smell of fudge again pervades the air. Hugh Orde, Peter Hain and Jonathan Powell need to wake up and smell the coffee. They have less than three months to put the UVF out of business – before the UVF puts them out of business. Permanently. The Committee On Evil Literature[Spotted in the Guardian] A fascinating piece by Robbie Meredith on The Committee On Evil Literature, appointed by Kevin O'Higgins in 1926, and the history of censorship in modern Ireland, on Radio3's Twenty Minutes on Tuesday - listen here[RealPlayer audio file].. or go here. Interesting contributions from writer John McGahern and Tom Garvin, Professor of Politics at University College Dublin.. over 12,000 titles banned throughout the 20th Century.. but not Jimmy Joyce's Ulysses.. and while the report ends by pointing out that no literature has been banned for well over a decade, the last book released from a banning order?.. Sex by Madonna.. banned in 1992.. released on 31 December 2004. Update More information on The Committee On Evil Literature is available from the National Archive website Just a Mo...THE former Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, Mo Mowlam, has died. I doubt the she will ever be forgotten, for different reasons, and her unique style was something NI had never experienced before from someone in such a position - remember Mayhew? She was much beloved of many here, although unionists had many problems with her irreverence and perceived sympathy for Irish nationalism. Few will forget her; she got a standing ovation longer than the Prime Minister's at a Labour Party conference; she visited loyalist terrorists in the Maze prison, as she believed it help secure the Agreement; opposed the war in Iraq; called Martin McGuinness "babe" while bugging his car (McGuinness kindly blames NIO securocrats in his tribute); called for the legalisation of all drugs; and (depending on which source you believe) she once asked a police officer, senior civil servant or Peter Mandelson to pop out and buy her some tampons. On a more personal level, Mo was very likeable. On the few occasions I met her, she took the time to talk, and was chatty, personable and down to earth. She could be blunt too. Her first official visit as SoS was to Ballymena, and she was very well received. I have little doubt about what she would say if she were able to go back there today. She was very human, but that means she made mistakes, just like the rest of us. After the murder of Charles Bennett by the IRA, she defined it as 'internal housekeeping', rather than the breach of a ceasefire. The legacy of that throwaway comment is still with us today, as loyalists slaughter each other, while the Government stands idly by and watches. Talking to Mo wasn't like talking to a politician. Some people who had meetings with her thought it was more like talking to a rather vulgar child, and I recall being told by one politician how she used to take off her wig and twirl it round her fingers when she had heard enough. Appalled by her brazenness and scared of her popularity, she was heavily briefed against when she fell out of favour. Mo had little time for airs and graces, and she was widely regarded by the public as 'one of us', a regular person (though maybe a wee bit too rude and touchy-feely for a rather conservative place like NI), the child of an alcoholic father who battled bravely against illness, and brought a more human face to politics here. In her own words, "a tough old boot". ADDS: There's a good backgrounder on her illness and wig here. No forward planning on the Colombia question?I'm struggling a bit with the Colombia three story. Some months ago we posed a question as to what might happen when they returned to Dublin. It seems that this took most of the Dublin political (and to a lesser extent journalistic) establishment by surprise. Today in the Irish Times Davy Adams argues (subs required) that most of the recent Sinn Fein moves have been aimed at undermining the integrity of the Taoiseach: In claiming to have a personal commitment from Bertie Ahern on speaking rights in the Dáil for Northern Ireland's MPs and MEPs, Gerry Adams deliberately raised suspicions of secret deals having been done in advance of the IRA statement. This led to questions being asked regarding the nature and, indeed, the purpose of a series of private meetings involving Adams and Ahern. By the time a Sinn Féin spokesman belatedly acknowledged that the Taoiseach was correct in his denials, the ground had been laid for the next, far more serious, assault on Bertie Ahern's integrity. It's worth looking Pete's recent post on Ahern's more than two year old commitment to look at the issue in the context of Seanad reform. He also argues that the return of the Columbia Three has put the Republic in diplomatic hot water with President Bush. Althou A-levels getting easier...A YEAR from today, I wouldn't be surprised if there was a front page with the headline '100% success for all A-Level students'. Perhaps it's because the discredited exams are getting easier. Well aren't they? August 18, 2005 Could DU(P) better...THE DUP is still coming under fire for not doing enough to combat sectarian attacks in the Ballymena area, and with a loyalist parade in Rasharkin tomorrow night, more trouble is expected from the knuckledraggers behind the violence. Concerned about future republican activity, the DUP is saying plenty about the imminent demise of the RIR and police station closures. Yet it has said comparatively little about those who present the biggest threat to both its unionist voters and Catholic constituents in North Antrim - the loyalists that DUP politicians were content to be seen mingling with in Ballymena recently. If the DUP expended half the energy it does on giving off about the IRA threat of violence (real or imagined) and channelled it into ending loyalist attacks, we might get somewhere. Nevertheless, PA reported that a DUP spokesman said his party was treating Gerry Kelly's comments "with contempt", given his background. "Sinn Fein/IRA has terrorised the community for 35 years spreading violence and criminality," the spokesman said. "Even yet they refuse to give information to the police. "The DUP position on all attacks is clear. Our representatives have condemned wholeheartedly all such attacks and have asked anyone with information to help the police." The position is so clear that we had photographs in the Press of Councillor Robin Sterling of the DUP's 'spiritual wing' standing beside someone waving a UDA flag the other night at a loyalist protest against a republican parade in Ballymena. Perhaps the DUP is afraid of losing support in its terrorist-supporting fanbase. So even when Paisley finally did speak out against the widespread campaign of loyalist intimidation against his constituents, it rang somewhat hollow. Paisley said: "Last week when the mayor (of Ballymena, DUP councillor Tommy Nicholl) unreservedly condemned any and all such attacks, he spoke with the authority of my party and it goes without saying that I too condemn these attacks and call for them to end." It most certainly does not "go without saying" that Mr Paisley condemns loyalist attacks, since his words have contributed to them happening in the past. On holiday or not, there's little doubt Mr Paisley should have had plenty to say about a low-level terrorist campaign in his adopted home town. Equally, when the PSNI officer responsible for policing Ahoghill - where many of the loyalist attacks have taken place recently - remarks that "[t]here`s no doubt that there`s an element of sectarianism, but also an element of people just not getting on with each other", one wonders what exactly churches and schools have to do with any disputes between individuals. Such attacks on identifibly 'Catholic' targets are naked sectarianism, and while they may not have the sanction of any organisation (or even if they do), it does not absolve the PSNI of the fact that they are policing a very small village with next to nothing to show for their investigation. What’s going on with the UVF?Danny Morrison writing in Daily Ireland poses some questions. Remember how often over the past thirty years we were told that loyalist paramilitary violence was solely a response to the activities of the IRA? We heard that mantra ad nauseam from unionist politicians and loyalist spokespersons alike. It was echoed in police press statements and in the tenor of early media reporting describing the murders of Catholics as “tit-for-tat” or “retaliatory” killings. They told us that if there was no IRA or IRA activity there would be no loyalist paramilitaries or loyalist violence. It was a perverted logic that allowed unionists to spuriously claim that the IRA was thus responsible for all 3,500 deaths. But it is obvious from the history of Ulster unionism, including the illegal activities of the first UVF and its subsequent co-option into the state forces, that there has always been a dependant relationship between unionism and the use or threat of extra-parliamentary violence. When Will We Hear The UVF’s Real Plan? By Danny Morrison Ian Paisley is on his holidays. The four entirely independent members of the Independent Monitoring Commission are on holidays. Peter Hain is the Secretary of State for Wales. Sir Hugh Orde is damned elusive. Where are all the ‘peace’ groups and those politicians opposed to paramilitary violence, drug-pushers and criminality? Lord Rooker?.. Mister Hain would like a wordI happen to agree with Lord Rooker - "Let's face it, the structure of the 11 [Assembly] departments is absolutely barmy. It's illogical." - but I doubt that Secretary of State, Peter Hain, would want him to say that in an interview with the Belfast Telegraph. As David Gordon notes in the article - "Lord Rooker is the Government's Northern Ireland spokesman in the Lords, as well as being Minister for Agriculture, Environment, Finance and Personnel and the Office of the First and Deputy First Minister (OFMDFM). and of that umbrella he said - "Every week, I find something new I am responsible for. I'm the women's minister, for starters. That takes a bit of explaining." Indeed. He also had this to say about being the Labour Party's spokesman on NI in the House of Lords "The Lords Ministers work harder than the Commons Ministers - you may quote me on that by the way," he says. Rooker, old chap, you're being quoted on everything.. as I'm sure the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland [and Wales], Peter Hain, will remind you. And David Gordon ends the interview with - Lord Rooker says: "I'm not envisaging that I'm here for the long-term." facing extradition proceedingsNo, not that extradition case. This is another case. Leonard Hardy, who served 5 years in the Republic of Ireland for possession of explosives in 1990, was arrested in Spain today on a warrant issued by the authorities in Germany. According to the RTE report, he is wanted for questioning about an IRA attack on a British Army base in Osnabruck in 1989 and the attempted murder of a British Army employee.. the Belfast Telegraph also has a report.. and the BBC has Sinn Féin TD Arthur Morgan's reaction - "It is my firm view this man should be released and allowed to return home to his family in Ireland without any further delay." Mo Mowlam near deathJust seen the Evening Standard's front page (latest edition) and it's reporting that Mo Mowlam is close to death and has breathing difficulties. She made a living will and stipulated that she did not want to be kept alive artificially. Let's hope that her death, when it comes, is peaceful and gentle. She will surely be missed around the Labour party conference circuit and all the campaigns and organisations that she was involved in - including the Integrated Education Fund. Colombia 3 Quizzed by GardaiThe Colombia Three are being questioned in police stations in Dublin. McCartney sisters win German awardTim Berners Lee and the McCartney sisters are recipients of a Quadriga Award for courage, vision and responsibility. Thanks to Neil for the heads up! Woke up this morning...EMINEM has cancelled his appearance at Slane Castle, meaning disappointment for thousands of fans north and south. But fear not, as the far superior Alabama 3 (of Sopranos theme tune fame)are playing in Lisburn tomorrow night. Sinn Féin launch dossierSinn Féin have launched a dossier(pdf) highlighting attacks from Unionist Paramilitary groups over the summer months. Speaking at the press conference Mr Kelly said: "The following report details unionist paramilitary activity since the beginning of June. "It details over 85 instances of unionist paramilitary activity, including five murders in a period of just over two months. "Although by no means comprehensive, due to the fact that many attacks and acts of intimidation go unreported, it offers a chilling picture of a campaign of orchestrated sectarian intimidation, particularly in areas where there is a vulnerable nationalist minority. JUNE 2005 JULY 2005 AUGUST 2005 Embarrassment for Rooker...AS Labour is in thrall to the large supermarkets, Lord Rooker's arrogant and controversial decision to give the go-ahead to a John Lewis superstore at Sprucefield was perhaps unsurprising. Now it appears it may be coming back to haunt him already, as he announces the delay of planning policies until legal challenges to his decision have been dealt with. The NIO is reportedly split over the Minister's decision, which - given that the new retailing policies were in the immediate offing at the time it was taken - now seems premature. Sectarianism? The PSNI aren’t sureA week after the murder of 15 year old Thomas Devlin the PSNI reveal they think the attack may have been sectarian but their minds are open. Meanwhile back in Ahoghill Deputy Chief Constable Paul Leighton (Irish News, subs req) has disputed assertions the ongoing campaign of attacks on Catholics in the village are entirely sectarian preferring to speculate there may be an element of “not getting on with each other” instead. 6 coins.. 6 designs.. up to £30,000 prizeThe Royal Mint have announced an open competition to replace the reverse designs on the 1p, 2p, 5p, 10p and 50p coins by Christopher Ironside, introduced in 1971, and the 20p reverse design by William Gardner introduced in 1982 [ N.B. not the obverse design as the Guardian reports *shakes head*]. You can download the full design brief here.. and, if you want to submit a design, you have until 14 November 2005. August 17, 2005 Hitler beats Blair in leadership pollAs if things couldn' t get any worse - just seen this on Sky news website......... Is it possible that the current endless offering of programmes about the Nazis etc could have altered some people's views of Hitler - another case of revisionism - albeit very slowly? Hitler Beats Blair In Leadership Poll Nazi dictator Adolf Hitler has beaten Tony Blair in a new poll as one of the greatest leaders of all time.A firm asked 1,000 business leaders who they rated as as the most impressive leaders of men throughout history.The German fuehrer came 20th in the list while the Prime Minister could only manage 25th. Top of the list is Hitler's nemisis Winston Churchill. Gandhi, the man who led India to independence, is second. Former South African president Nelson Mandela is third. Ex-Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher - dubbed The Iron Lady - came in at number eight. Top sportsman was Lance Armstrong, the cycling legend who beat cancer and went on to claim a record number of Tour de France wins. Some dictators made it into the top poll for leadership skills other than Hitler. Mao-Tse-Tung, who led the Chinese communist revolution, came in at 31. Veteran Cuban leader Fidel Castro was 41st. The list was complied ahead of a conference of business leaders to be held in London in October. Organiser Rosalind Oxley said: "Bob Geldof just about makes it into our Top 50. "But it is slightly disturbing to see him beaten by Hitler, who also ranks higher than the Dalai Lama and Mother Teresa." Ireland is now a 'legitimate' targetProbably not totally unexpected, but deeply depressing nevertheless, The Belfast Telegraph reports that Anjem Choudary, who has close links to the infamous hate preacher, Omar Bakri Mohammed, said the use of Shannon Airport as a stop-off for US warplanes justifies Ireland being attacked. Are we well equipped for this after 30 years of 'home grown' terrorism and conflict which have left an indelible mark in the hearts and minds of people both North and South? Belfast Telegraph Home > News Islamic cleric says Ireland is a 'legitimate target'
A notorious British-based Islamic extremist has said Ireland is a "legitimate" target for al-Qa'ida terror attacks. Anjem Choudary, who has close links to the infamous hate preacher, Omar Bakri Mohammed, said the use of Shannon Airport as a stop-off for US warplanes justifies Ireland being attacked. The solicitor (38) said: "If your government wants to support the atrocities in Afghanistan they can expect some repercussions," and added that Ireland had "opened itself" to attacks from radical Muslims linked to al-Qa'ida. Choudary even said that terrorists have the right to kill indiscriminately since American bombers did not pick and choose military targets in Iraq. CONDEMNING He said he was "not in the business" of condemning terrorist attacks in Britain and Ireland and added: "What you need to do is you need to be responsible and you need to look after your national security. "If people slipped into Ireland from Iraq, Afghanistan or elsewhere, where the Irish are standing side by side with the butcher of Baghdad, George Bush, then they would have a legitimacy for that type of thing. "That's not my personal opinion but your asking me what it says in the Koran." Choudary believes that Ireland has risked being targeted by opening up Shannon to planes transporting US troops to Iraq. "Obviously if Ireland is allowing their land to be used for planes to fly and to bomb Muslims, then those Muslims will obviously have a right to retaliate, it goes without saying." He also criticises Irish Muslims, saying they've been "stripped of their Islamic personality through secular education. On the one hand they're not willing to speak up and on the other hand they're intimidated into being docile." Choudary joined Omar Bakri Mohammed's al-Muhajiroun extremists in the late 1990s and became the cleric's spokesperson and advisor. He hailed the September 11 attacks as a "towering day in history" and hailed the hijackers as "magnificent martyrs". Among the targets that the extremist believes are legitimate include hospitals, women and children. "So this is the nature of war, people don't make love in war do they? They'll kill each other. If you fire a nuclear weapon they will fire a nuclear weapon back."
Bush the bookwormSome interesting and surprising titles on Dubya's holiday reading list - well he is off for 5 weeks. Just hope he doesn't try and read them upside down! Bookworm Bush's holiday reading Jamie Wilson in Washington
As well as brush cutting, mountain biking and fishing, the president will also be tucking into Salt: A World History by Mark Kurlansky during his five-week summer sojourn on his Texas ranch. The other tomes are reported to be Alexander II: the Last Great Tsar by Edvard Radzinsky and The Great Influenza: The Epic Story of the Deadliest Plague in History by John M Barry. Article continues "There's nothing on that list that is a beach read, or even a busman's holiday," Peter Osnos, of the PublicAffairs publishing house, told the Los Angeles Times. "It's a fair bet that George Bush is the only person in the entire US who chose those three books to read on vacation." Kurlansky, whose book charts the rise and fall of what was once seen as the world's most strategic commodity, said he was surprised Mr Bush had taken his 484-page book to the ranch. "My first reaction was, 'Oh, he reads books?'" The president, who has often been ridiculed for his occasional mangling of the English language, has gone out of his way to let people know he does read books and newspapers. But that has not stopped some advisers from highlighting his literary deficiencies. He is "often uncurious and as a result ill-informed", his former speechwriter David Frum wrote in his memoir, adding that "conspicuous intelligence seemed actively unwelcome in the Bush White House". Earlier this year his wife, Laura, told the White House Correspondents Association dinner: "George and I were just meant to be ... I was the librarian who spent 12 hours a day in the library, yet somehow I met George." Nazi group rears its ugly head in NIAccording to a report in the Belfast Telegraph, it looks like Combat 18 has a presence in Garvagh (Co. Derry/Londonderry). As NI society is slowing becoming more diverse in terms of ethnicity and culture is it inevitable that this will also be reflected in a rise of racist violence and attitudes and if so how can this bigotry be stemmed? Nazi posters spread fear in a quiet village By Linda McKee A sinister right-wing group is targeting homes and property in a Co Londonderry village with a poster campaign, it was last night warned. SDLP Assembly member John Dallat said residents of Garvagh had complained that notices announcing the return of the ultra-right wing Combat 18 had been pasted around the village. The East Londonderry MLA said Combat 18 was linked to loyalist elements in the Coleraine and Bushmills areas. "Catholic homes and businesses have been specifically targeted, but these sinister stickers have also appeared on traffic islands and are similar to others which were erected in areas of Coleraine last year where black people are known to work," he said. "Recently, a nurse from the Philippines fled the village of Garvagh after her flat was broken into and money stolen." Mr Dallat said he had alerted the PSNI to what was a sinister form of racism and intimidation. "While I don't regard those involved as having any support among the intelligent population I do believe the Hate Crime laws should be applied and those involved prosecuted," he said. "We need to be very mindful that there is a sizeable population of people from many parts of the world now living and working in this area. "While there isn't a pattern of racist attacks it is important that no opportunities are afforded to anyone who would want to reintroduce Combat 18 or any other corrupt elements bent on causing division and distrust." A Police spokesman said they took such incidents extremely seriously, and added: "The PSNI would appeal to anyone who is aware of such hate literature or knows of anyone distributing such literature to contact their local police station immediately." Bowled overEngland's performances during the Ashes series have seen interest in cricket as well as Channel 4 viewing figures soaring Two Steps Forward; One Step BackIn today's Irish Times (subs. req.)Vincent Browne argues that not only is the question of the extradition or imprisonment of the Colombia Three an irrelevance - given that the US Administration could not care less about the issue (or Ireland in general for that matter) as long as the Government continues to make Shannon available to military aircraft and supports the US in UN votes - but also that, contrary to claims from some media quarters, their reappearance in Ireland does not represent the same old cynical IRA modus operandi or the "one step forward; two steps back" scenario posited by Fintan O'Toole on Monday's Newsnight. August 16, 2005 Ultimate 'tumbleweed' moments #21A post-Patten PSNI officer has been pinned with of chanting pro-PIRA slogans at a staff party piss up, PA reports. The policeman is to appear before a disciplinary panel, and could face the possibility of severe penalties if found guilty. Paisley Minor is predictably perturbed. Alan Erwin wrote: A detective from the Police Service of Northern Ireland's Internal Investigation Branch has spent six months on the case. He was appointed to probe complaints made after staff at a PSNI station held their annual Christmas party in a south Belfast hotel. Off-duty officers had been drinking heavily when the remarks were allegedly made. Sir Hugh, who was challenged on the affair at a Policing Board meeting, disclosed the developments in a letter to chairman Sir Desmond Rea. He said: "The investigation has now concluded and the officer is to appear before a misconduct panel to answer alleged breaches of the Code of Ethics." It is understood the officer involved only joined the police service in the last two years. He was among the first to be drafted in under plans to transform the overwhelmingly Protestant force. But his career is now in the balance as he faces the possibility of tough disciplinary action. (Remind me to unlock this thread's comments when the case is over.) NIO spins aimlessly on UVF murdersClearly stung by the criticism noted earlier, the NIO have issued another statement, atttributed to an unnamed NIO Spokesperson, on the latest UVF murder - one day after the supposed Minister, Lord Rooker, issued this statement. The BBC report appears to incorrectly attribute the new statement to Secretary of State, Peter Hain, but it just refers to a previous statement by Hain, from 1 August or, maybe, 29 July. More importantly, IMO, the NIO Spokesperson is now acknowledging that, after repeating Hain's statement that the issue is gangsterism masqerading as loyalism, "NIO officials continue to be in close contact with community leaders in loyalism to try to bring this ongoing violence to an end. Ministers also remain in close contact with PSNI and security officials." A question for the NIO spokesperson - Who are these community leaders in loyalism that NIO officials are in close contact with?.. and, indeed, who are the leaders in the gangsterism masquerading as loyalism? i.e. the people the Secretary of State Peter Hain holds responsible for the violence.. just to clarify the situation, you understand.
Tuesday 16 August 2005 NIO condemns loyalist violence NI Priest to stand trial in KenyaCo. Fermanagh priest is to stand trial in Kenya for organising a lands right protest. He was put in prison but released on bail on Monday. Interesting to see what actions will be taken by the Catholic hierarchy to campaign on his behalf. Last Updated: Monday, 15 August 2005, 21:58 GMT 22:58 UK
Fr Gabriel Dolan, who comes from Derrygonnelly, was arrested at the weekend in the rural town of Kitale after a demonstration. He was put in prison but released on bail on Monday. Fr Dolan is an outspoken critic of the Kenyan government's land policies and has been involved in campaigning for the rights of the poor.
From Buerk to a Berk?BBC newsreader Michael Buerk has obviously got a bit 'hot under the collar' about the prominence of women in the BBC and beyond and bemoans the fact that it is no longer a man's world. Is he just out of step or is he reflecting some widely held male fears/beliefs? Men are now 'unemployable sperm donors', says Buerk Claire Cozens and agencies Former BBC newsreader Michael Buerk has risked provoking the ire of his bosses by claiming that that the "shift in the balance of power between the sexes" has gone too far, and men are now little more than "sperm donors". Buerk cited women in the top jobs in BBC broadcasting as an example, saying "these are the people who decide what we see and hear", and said society needs to admit there is a problem. "Life is now being lived according to women's rules", he told the Radio Times. "The traits that have traditionally been associated with men - reticence, stoicism, single-mindedness - have been marginalised. "The result is that men are becoming more like women. Look at the men who are being held up as sporting icons - David Beckham and, God forbid, Tim Henman." The former Nine O'Clock News presenter said some changes have been for the good, but asked: "What are the men left with?" "Men gauge themselves in terms of their career, but many of those have disappeared. All they are is sperm donors, and most women aren't going to want an unemployable sperm donor loafing around and making the house look untidy. They are choosing not to have a male in the household." Buerk, whose views will also be screened in a Five series on personal hobbyhorses, Don't Get Me Started!, this week, said that when he started making the programme he "came across what I considered a very personal example of the changes that have taken place". "Almost all the big jobs in broadcasting were held by women - the controllers of BBC1 television and Radio 4 for example. These are the people who decide what we see and hear." The BBC1 controller, Lorraine Heggessey, has since left the BBC and been replaced by a man, Peter Fincham, while BBC4 is still run by Janice Hadlow. Recently one of the BBC's most influential former director generals, Alasdair Milne, sparked a furious response when he accused the corporation of producing "terrible" programmes and laid the bla Government recognition of UVF ceasefire is a "crackpot situation".There's a lot of coverage of yesterday's murder in Belfast today, from the Irish Examiner to The Guardian.. and all points between.. the fourth killing by the UVF in the past 6 weeks.. but while Lord Rooker, When two political cultures meet?Nuala O'Faolain in the Sunday Tribune last week was in no mood for pulling punches. She was in no mood to accept Sinn Fein's latest proposal that Northern Irish MPs should be given speaking rights in the Dail. But what really troubles her is the effects of unleashing a political project, whose development took place in the extreme political conditions of Northern Ireland, in what she calls 'this peaceful Republic'. Firstly she argues: ...if northern Sinn Fein activists are not the evil monsters of the usual rants, neither are they just like me. A sdie issue of the Colombia Three affair brings home how far apart south and north are, after decades of separate development, in one crucial aspect. We lie differently. She goes on: Gerry Adams looks us in the face and denies he was ever on the Army Council of the IRA. And similarly, Sinn Fein knows nothing about where the bodies of the disappeared are, and their people did not rob the Northern Bank and so on and so forth. The fact is we're going to have to live with people to whom telling the truth has long since been subsumed to other aims. In south, she argues, lying is also the poltlical weapon of choice. But she contrasts the relatively trivial nature of political spin around the changing of licensing laws and the shooting of red deer. Looking forward she imagines: There will be a certain comedy in watching the two cultures learn each other's ways. But there's a lot of fear there, too. Northern Sinn Fein is a creature of far more extreme conditions than we have ever known. Nobody knows whether it will turn out to be better at, or a scourge to, the habits of dishonesty of this peaceful Republic. Either way, here comes trouble. a most serious juncture in politics and democracy on this islandThe Parnell Summer School opened at the weekend.. and Fine Gael leader Enda Kenny certainly pulled no punches in his speech. The Irish Times reported the speech yesterday.. and SF Cllr Christy Burke's immediate reaction at the event - "Mr Burke remonstrated with Mr Kenny after the speech, particularly on the issue of the party's involvement with narcotics" - the full text of the speech is available from the Fine Gael website From Tim O'Brien in the Irish Times - Mr Kenny said there was an extraordinary tolerance of Sinn Féin activity by the media and the Government. He said if he or any other party leader had been involved with the "Colombia Three" they would be probably subjected to extraordinary scrutiny. The text from the Fine Gael website shows that Enda Kenny was also highly critical of both Sinn Féin president Gerry Adams.. and the media treatment of him - Gerry Adams gave his usual performance on RTÉ last week on the apparition of the so-called Colombia Three, proving once again, that this particular artist favours politics by pronouncement: no interruption, no contradiction, no questions, no analysis would be, could be, tolerated. It was the word according to Sinn Féin. And it went unchallenged. He continued in his criticism of the Irish Government - Regrettably, the current government has compromised its integrity to such a degree on so many fronts, not least on the reprehensible deal to release the killers of Detective Garda Jerry McCabe that you begin to suspect that another deal, even on the Holy of Holies that is Northern Ireland, could become just one more episode of serial compromise. The Tánaiste and the Progressive Democrats may bleat all they like. But, they are the Government. They do the deals every bit as much as Fianna Fáil. and concluded with this challenge to Bertie Ahern - This is a most serious juncture in politics and democracy on this island. Today, on the eve of the seventh anniversary of the Omagh Bomb, I’m saying clearly to the Taoiseach, that it’s time, now, for him to leave his political comfort zone. It’s time to stand not by the republicans. But, by the Republic. Baccalaureate to shake up 'flexible' A levelsIt's always good to see someone taking policy issue seriously. A Yank in Ulster looks at a proposal by Estelle Morris in today's Guardian, not to abolish A Levels as such, but to introduce a common standard International Baccalaureate-style diploma to run alongside A Levels - and let the schools chose which one to run with. With some of the elite Universities pulling their corporate hair looking for a reliable marker for excellence - it may just catch on. It may also challenge those schools currently shopping around for the test company believed to give the best A-level scores. Overreaction to Colombia Three?Taking a very quick break from holidays. Eilis O'Hanlon thinks that a lot of the critical reaction to the IRA's statement and, most recently, the return of the Columbia 3 (or one of them at least) has been needlessly hysterical and counterproductive. She believes latest events a distraction for the Republican heartland constituency: First, they make some sort of vague commitment that gets maximum publicity, then send General John de Chastelain back to Canada empty handed. Soon they're standing around with placards watching the watchtowers come down in west Belfast and south Armagh. Next they claim that speaking rights in the Dail for Sinn Fein's Westminster MPs are somehow in the offing. Finally they produce the proverbial rabbit out of the hat with the Colombia Three. She sees them as: ...morale-boosting stunts to a movement which knows at heart that the game is up. The IRA statement may have been less historic or definitive than it was portrayed by the media, but the IRA still ate dirt that day, hedged about as it may have been with rhetorical provisos and fancy language extolling the struggle. She's scathing about the import of such activity: The IRA didn't even battle it out honourably for a score draw. They lost, which is why they're still subjects of Her Majesty the Queen - the ending of which status was the single objective with which they started out - and destined to remain that way for decades and decades, under constant probation, with every descent into criminality only extending their UK residency.August 15, 2005 Final acts of settlement...?ISRAEL is going through a painful, but essential, step at the moment, according to its leader Ariel Sharon. As Israel dismantles settlements built on Palestinian land seized in the Six-Day War in 1967 for the first time, troops have encountered hardline Jewish resistance to the Gaza pull-out, although the lack of extreme violence (at present) would seem to indicate that this is a last gasp act of defiance. Inspector's gadgets fail to impress...THE use of plastic bullets in Northern Ireland has often been criticised by republicans (whose own 'police' prefer live rounds), but finding a 'less lethal' replacement to contain riots has proved difficult for the Government. In a story yesterday - which reads like a report about weapons experiments carried out by Q's office in a Bond movie - we learn of the many failed attempts by State scientists to devise a crowd control weapon that doesn't breach human rights legislation. Another killing in the loyalist feud...ON the way to work this morning I saw a large police presence in Shaftesbury Square, not far from loyalist Sandy Row, which runs parallel to Belfast's 'Golden Mile' of bars and restaurants. The news came later that another man had been murdered in the ongoing feud between the UVF and LVF. The police seem to be impotent, and most people seem to expect more bloodshed on the streets before this turf war ends. The Bill Clinton CollectionA Bill Clinton compilation CD has been put together (available in 5 weeks) and one of the 11 tracks on the CD is Phil Coulter's 'The Town I Love So Well' . Is this setting a (dangerous) precedent for political leaders? CD launch for Bill Clinton tunes
A compilation CD featuring some of former US President Bill Clinton's favourite rock 'n' roll, jazz and gospel songs is to be released. The Bill Clinton Collection: Selections from the Clinton Music Room will be the first in a series of CDs of the former president's favourite tunes. Artists featured on the albums include John Coltrane, Miles Davis, Nina Simone and Judy Collins. The 11-track CD will go on sale at the Clinton Museum Store in Arkansas. Clinton's tunes My One and Only Love - John Coltrane
She said: "I wanted to make sure his CD was going on when he came into the store. "Not six foot in the door, he stopped, looked at me and said: 'What is that?' He took the demo and by the time he got to the golf course, all the windows of his car were down and he was blasting it." The CD is the latest joint venture for the museum and shop. The museum is running a temporary exhibit until the end of the year on Clinton's love for music, including a replica of the music room built for him at the White House. The Clinton Presidential Foundation has been working for months to acquire licensing rights to certain tracks. The CD is expected to go on sale in four to five weeks.
Fly Fly AwayPlans afoot for a local N.I. -based, budget airline to fly from Belfast and Dublin to Continental Europe. Can only be good as they say travel broadens the mind!
Belfast Telegraph Home > News Ulster's own airline set for take-off next year
A group of Ulster entrepreneurs is hatching plans to launch a new airline that will be based in Northern Ireland, The Belfast Telegraph has learned. Sources close to the group said it has secured financial backing for the project and its services will take off next summer. It is understood the airline will offer flights from both Belfast and Dublin to destinations throughout Europe. The group is believed to have signed a memorandum of understanding with an aircraft company for the provision of aircraft. Sources said the individual entrepreneurs involved have signed a confidentiality agreement which does not allow any of them to go public on the group's plans until schedules are firmed up. It is understood the airline will pitch its services at the no-frills market which is currently dominated by easyJet in Northern Ireland. EasyJet now has five aircraft based at Belfast International Airport where it currently operates nine scheduled services to Britain and 10 to destinations on the continent. Sources said the airline would be based in Belfast, but the entrepreneurs have not decided which of Belfast's two airports will be its home. It is likely to be based at Belfast International, which has embraced no-frills services, rather than Belfast City, which largely concentrates on full service flights. However, Belfast City is the base for low cost airline Flybe, which last week revealed that 111,529 passengers flew with it to and from the city in June. Belfast International seems a more likely destination for its home at present because the City Airport is currently subject to stiff traffic restrictions, including a passenger limit of 1.5 million outbound and 1.5 million inbound, although this is currently under review. Total passenger numbers at Belfast International were 4.5 million last year and are Guy Fawkes anniversary party?Given recent events in London and the general mood re the 'war on terror', it's probably unlikely that the origianl plans to do something in the Palce of Westminster. However York seems to be more than happy to celebrate one of its most famous sons.... York celebrates its famous son (the one who tried to blow up Parliament) The delicate issue of how to commemorate the 400th anniversary of a terror plot conceived by religious extremists has caused a House of Commons firework display and an ITV documentary to be abandoned in the past few months. The city of York is, however, less coy about its most notorious son's part in the plot. Smoking ban coming to a public house near you?It looks like it's only a matter of time before pubs in Britain and NI follow the example of the ROI and become smokefree. Will it be as smooth a transition? Majority of MPs 'support pub smoking ban' Have your say in the government's consultation Matthew Tempest and agencies More than two-thirds of MPs want the government to go further than its planned anti-smoking legislation and ban smoking in all pubs, a survey found today. The government is consulting on legislation to outlaw smoking in all licensed premises which serve food, leaving private members' clubs and those pubs serving just peanuts and crisps unaffected. However, according to a poll of MPs conducted for the anti-smoking groups Cancer Research UK and Action on Smoking and Health (Ash), there is a cross-party consensus for a complete ban, similar to those introduced in New York and Ireland and soon to be brought in in Scotland. Doctors and anti-smoking campaigners are hoping that ministers will change their minds and opt for an outright ban.
The survey of 140 MPs from all parties found that 69% would support a smoke-free law covering all workplaces - including pubs - without the exemptions currently proposed. More than three-quarters (77%) agreed that a widespread smoke-free law would make it more pleasant to visit public places. And 75% believed that smoking in workplaces ought to be prohibited to prevent people acting in a way that might harm others. Some 91% agreed that the government had a responsibility to try to make people's lives healthier by actively discouraging smoking. The survey found that support for a smoke-free law had risen sharply since the last parliament, with just 51% of MPs surveyed last year in favour. The survey included 80 Labour MPs, 45 Conservatives, 22 Liberal Democrats and six MPs from smaller parties in order to reflects the make-up of the Commons. Campaigners now believe that the vast majority of responses to the government's consultation, which ends on September 5, will back a comprehensive ban, dropping the current exemptions. Jean King, Cancer Research UK's director of tobacco control, said: "Support for comprehensive smoke-free legislation is strong among MPs, and continues to grow. "Many recent opinion polls have shown high public support for the measure, and it has been popular in Ireland. "The government cannot ignore the majority voice of people and politicians. Introducing legislation with exemptions and loopholes would deny protection to the many thousands of workers in the hospitality industry who are currently exposed to high levels of second-hand smoke." Deborah Arnott, director of Ash, said it was clear from the survey that most MPs - along with most members of the public - now wanted a comprehensive smokefree law. "This is a critical and overdue public health reform," she said. "It will protect the health of workers and members of the public in currently smoke-filled workplaces. It will encourage many smokers to quit their lethal habit. It will save thousands of lives. "Patricia Hewitt must find the political will to follow the Scottish and Irish example. A Department of Health spokeswoman said: "The proposal in the white paper to make smoke-free bars and pubs that prepare and serve food was based on many factors. "Public opinion was crucial to the decision that was made and showed that the public were far less supportive of measures to make all bars and pubs smoke-free. "We are currently consulting on the proposals in the white paper before legislation goes to parliament, and we will look carefully at all the evidence put forward." Forest, the smokers' lobby group, have launched a public awareness campaign aimed at rejecting a statutory ban in favour of more no-smoking zones and better ventilation, which they say it the public's preferred choice. According to the government, smoking causes more than 100,000 deaths in the UK each year while treating smoking-related diseases costs the NHS about £1.7bn annually. August 13, 2005Army sold out...DID anyone see the British military watchtower (possibly being dismantled in Derry) that was 'auctioned' on eBay a day or two ago? It seems to be gone now, but had attracted a bid of just over a million pounds before eBay presumably took it off the site... Ammunition was hidden, not dumpedI noted the Irish Examiner article on the ammunition find in Kerry on Tuesday.. and the generally low-key reaction. Today's Irish Independent has a report that would explain why - One senior garda said the ammunition had been there "for several years" and was "buried into the bank of the river". "It was hidden, not dumped." From the Irish Independent - However, they said they do not believe it had any links to the recent IRA statement ordering its members to dump arms. a united Ireland plagued by gangstersFrank Millar, in the Irish Times, reports the comments of the chief constable of West Yorkshire, Colin Cramphorn, the last deputy chief constable of the RUC and then acting chief constable of the PSNI, from this interview in the Yorkshire Evening Post - A former Northern Ireland police chief has predicted that a united Ireland will emerge in about 15 years but that "it will be like Sicily" with "self-policing" by Mafia-type organisations. Millar picks out some of the comments from the article, in particular - He does not see the present process providing a smooth transition to a "normal" democracy. "I think in about 15 or so years we will see the unification of Ireland. And it will be like Sicily. And also points to this quote, from the interview in the Yorkshire Evening Post with Colin Cramphorn, on future organised criminal activity - "Neither is the IRA about to go away, it won't be abandoning its organised criminal activity. This is the most sophisticated, politically strategic organisation I know. It's a global business, it runs like clockwork – and it has pensions to pay to loyal volunteers and operatives who have given long service. Pensions are promised, they are in the contracts. These people are looked after and they are looked after well. This is not the end of the IRA, it is the beginning of another new era of it."August 12, 2005 Decommissioning delayed?RTE appear to carry confirmation, from Gardaí, of this morning's Irish Examiner report that thousands of rounds of ammunition - speculated to be for assault weapons - were dumped in North Kerry on Monday night. According to the IE's John Breslin [sound file], which seemed to be the only paper to cover the story, despite the find being made on Tuesday the Garda Press Office "said it had no information about the discovery of the ammunition." The Irish Examiner report also notes - ..Mr de Chastelain has returned to Canada and the other monitors are on holiday for most of the month. It could be next month before the [decommissioning] process begins. Mo Mowlam moved to hospiceJust seen this on the bbc's website. It looks like Mo's condition is worsening. Let's hope she's able to put up a brave fight. Mo Mowlam transferred to hospice
Critically ill former Northern Ireland Secretary Mo Mowlam has been moved from hospital to a hospice in Kent to be closer to her family. Ms Mowlam, 55, was taken to hospital in London two weeks ago. Hospital officials say her condition is still "critical but stable". She has now been transferred from King's College Hospital in London to Pilgrim Hospice in Canterbury, No details of her illness have been given by her doctors. The hospital has refused to say whether or not it is connected to her previous brain tumour. Jail talks Ms Mowlam, Labour MP for Redcar between 1987-2001, oversaw the talks which led to the 1998 Good Friday Agreement in Northern Ireland. In 1998, as Northern Ireland secretary, she went inside the Maze Prison when it became clear that the peace process would only succeed with the backing of the prisoners. The loyalist UDA/UFF prisoners had previously withdrawn their support for the process. She spoke to the prisoners face-to-face for 60 minutes, and two hours later the paramilitaries' political representatives announced they were being allowed to rejoin the talks. In 1999 she was replaced as Northern Ireland secretary by Peter Mandelson, and became Tony Blair's Cabinet Office "enforcer". She subsequently stood down as an MP and in recent years has pursued a career in the media. Historic murder trialLondon-based Irish World reports on an historic murder case where for the first time ever someone will stand trial in Britain for a murder that took place in Ireland. Murder trial makes history About that Titanic proposal..The £100million plan for development of a Titanic tourist project in Belfast's docklands area was heavily publicised in the media yesterday.. and the BBC report is online here. With a nice drawing too. But reading closely, there is no breakdown of the figures for private/public funding and, despite the reported unveiling of the plan by Belfast City Council and the Northern Ireland Tourist Board in the article, it currently only has the backing of Tourism sub-committee - the proposal, and an economic feasibility study, still has to clear the full council on 1 September. Be nice to see more details of the proposals.. somewhere. No mention of that Iceberg though... Irish Women take abortion demand to BrusselsThe (London-based) Independent covers the story of three Irish women (backed by the IFPA) taking their case to the European parliament in their quest to liberalise current legislation. Irish women take demand for abortions to Europe Three Irish women are to challenge their country's strict abortion laws by taking a test case to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. SomeThe Irish Times notes the local interest in the Man Booker Prize long-list - Three Irish writers compete for top award. But, while the Guardian praises the list and here, and here, compiled under the chairmanship of Guardian columnist Prof John Sutherland *ahem*... Sinéad at the Sigla Blog is less impressed - No surprises with the Booker List - but helpfully points to her interviews with two of the long-listed authors - Kazuo Ishiguro and John Banville. Also worth noting is DJ Taylor, also in the Guardian, arguing that "One conspicuous feature of this year's list is its profound metropolitan bias" More on John Banville at The Literary Encyclopedia, which as well as including information that the Irish Times neglected - he was previously the Literary Editor there and in 1999 became their Chief Critic [great job title btw] - also has a couple of noteworthy quotes - “I feel part of my culture. But it is a personal culture gleaned from bits and pieces of European culture of four thousand years.” Questioning the very notion of national literature – “there is no such thing as Irish national literature, only Irish writers engaged in the practice of writing” Indeed. August 10, 2005Who would live in a town like this?I dont think anyone else has blogged this, but there has been some discussion today of last night's Channel 4 programme 'Best and Worst Places to Live in the UK'. The programme ranked all of the Local Authorities across the UK looking at things such as educational performance, entertainment venues and employment. Coming in with the coveted title of third worse place to live in the UK was Strabane. The makers of the programme list Strabane's infamous unemployment rate as one of the main reasons for its poor showing in the poll but I'm not sure if they measured sheep worrying, as listed in the extended entry in the website, in every area. No Case to answer for Colombia Three?Ashling Reidy, Director of the Irish Council for Civil Liberties, believes (sound file) the Colombia Three may have no case to answer under Irish law and that Mary Harney's idea of charging them retrospectively under the Transfer of Execution of Sentences Bill 2003, which has "been gathering dust" for two years in the Seanad, simply won't fly as there are "huge impediments". Reidy says that the only Act the men could be charged under is the 1998 amendment to the Offences against the State Act, which brought in directing terrorism as an offence. However, the men were not found guilty of this in Colombia rather of Secondly, she also pointed out that Harney should realise that the Supreme Court is likely to throw out any attempt to make this law retrospective and cited its decision that attempts to pass retrospective decisions on nursing home charges was unconstitutional. Reidy points out that the men can also not be charged with travelling on false passports and only with forgery or possession of forged documents. They have already served their time for the possession on the outward journey so unless the Gardai have evidence of possession now, no warrant can be issued. There is also an interview with Harney and her saying the Colombia Three should go and have a chat with the Gardai. She says she thinks they are most certainly looking for them but refused to be drawn on whether Gerry Adams should ask in public for them to call into their local Garda station. She also refused to be drawn on whether they actually had a case to answer under Irish law.
Loyalist violence continues apaceLoyalist violence seems to be building up a head of steam with the latest in a series of pipebomb attacks on Catholic homes in Antrim taking place in Cloughmills. The Police Service of Northern Ireland say they will leave no stone unturned in the hunt for the perpetrators. “They always intensify and come to a head during the marching season.” Ian Stevenson, the deputy mayor of Ballymoney Borough Council, said: “I am not going to make any statements about the motive for the attack until I am in possession of all the facts.” Democratic Unionist Party councillor Roy Wilson said: “I condemn all attacks, loyalist or republican.” Maeve Connolly in the Irish News (courtesy of Nuzhound) says the attacks are reminiscent of the 2001 campaign against Catholics carried out by the UDA. manipulating public opinionThe Irish Times editorial today follows up on its, generally overlooked elsewhere, report yesterday in which Gerry Adams' chief spokesman [Gerry's on holiday dontchaknow] admitted that Adams was wrong when he claimed that the Taoiseach had given a commitment that "MPs elected in the six counties will be able to speak in the Dáil".. a claim which Ahern corrected, as noted here.. they had to unspin the admission though - SF admits Adams wrong on Dáil speaking rights "Perhaps Gerry wasn't qualified enough in what he wrote or didn't explain himself enough," he [Adams' spokesman] said From today's Irish Times editorial - It is difficult to understand why Mr Adams misrepresented the situation, last week, in an article published in this newspaper. He may have been annoyed by a succession of statements from the Democratic Unionist Party that entering government with Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland represented a long-term option for the party. In that context, raising the prospect of special Sinn Féin access to the Dáil was likely to antagonise loyalists while mollifying republicans. And, of course, the "Colombia Three" were about to reappear on the domestic scene. He should.. whether he will is a different matter. August 09, 2005Abortion issue resurfacesThe Irish Family Planning Association (IFPA) has launched a 13-point plan to have abortion legalised in the Irish Republic, under the motto ‘Safe and Legal in Ireland’. Strangely, while the 6,000 Irish women who travel to Britain and further afield annually to have abortions are discussed, there is no mention, in the press release at least (it was brought up before), of the supposed growing number of backstreet abortions carried out for those within the new immigrant community, who don't have the funds to travel or are afraid to leave the jurisdiction for fear of not being allowed back in.
the IFPA is calling for the removal of of Article 40.3.3 from the Constitution and says that abortion is a decision that should be made by a woman in consultation with her medical advisor. Article 40.3.3 states: "The State acknowledges the right to life of the unborn and, with due regard to the equal right to life of the mother, guarantees in its laws to respect, and, as far as practicable, by its laws to defend and vindicate that right." RTE reports that the campaign will include seeking meetings with the leaders of each political party to lobby them to change the current laws. Also, the Association is supporting three Irish women who have had abortions abroad and who are now taking a case to the European Court of Human Rights. The women say their human rights were breached by not being allowed have an abortion in Ireland. Anti-abortion group Youth Defence tried to break into the press conference and IFPA's Ivana Bacik, who ran for the European Parliament with Labour, said this is just the latest in a series of aggresive tactics against her and the organisation.
Colombia Three could be jailed in IrelandTánaiste Mary Harney, who is standing in for PD party colleague Michael McDowell as Minister for Justice, has said the Colombia Three shouldn't underestimate the Government's "determination to explore all the options open to it, to ensure that Ireland plays its full part in the fight against international terrorism". Harney said in a statement that the men were "no friends of the peace process" and insisted that no deal had been done with Sinn Féin. She added that the Transfer of Execution of Sentences Bill 2003, which is currently going through the Dáil, provides for a person to serve in Ireland a sentence imposed in the state from which they fled. “The question of the three men serving their sentences here in Ireland in the event of extradition proceedings being unsuccessful is one of the issues which the Government has been considering,” she said. The provisions of the Bill will apply before or after it is signed into law. Harney also revealed that Garda enquiries into where the men are hiding and whether they breached Irish laws were continuing but that while Colombian police had contacted Gardaí, no extradition request has yet been made. There are unconfirmed reports that the men have been in Ireland since March. Fire blankets for CatholicsThe Police Service of Northern Ireland have decided to issue fire blankets to Catholic families in the North Antrim village of Ahogill to help protect them from ongoing arson attacks by British loyalists. A PSNI spokesman told the BBC the action was "unprecedented". However, it was taken after fresh intelligence suggested more attacks were imminent. August 08, 2005 "a greeting to all Earthlings"Via the big G's Newsblog. Mission Specialist Number 2 Steve Robinson won't be too disappointed by the delay in the Space Shuttle Discovery returning from orbit. While he was waiting for Discovery to undock from the International Space Station, he recorded the first podcast from space [mp3 file can be downloaded at link] - "I would rather stay on the Space Station with Sergei and John and experience this strange, incredible life floating in Earth.. above the Earth.".. and take more cool photos like this one, no doubt. Update Well, they're finally Investigative politicsI noticed earlier that Mr has found time in his day to be annoyed at Peter Bowles call for Sinn Fein MLA Caitriona Ruane to be interviewed by the Police over the Columbia three incident. Interesting that she isn't the first Sinn Fein MLA to fall foul of Cllr Bowles. Towards a new GAAOrdinarily I try to avoid linking to the YU blog, but over the past couple of weeks, an interesting discussion has been taking place on this thread by former UYUC Chairman (and UUP DARD spokesman) Kenny Donaldson. He states that he is not a "GAA basher", but wishes to see the GAA move beyond its "outdated, discriminatory practices". facilitating committee discussionsIn a lengthy article on the state of the There has been much exaggerated comment on this point. What we have in mind is sensible but modest. It would not involve speaking rights or privileges in the Dáil, but rather facilitate committee discussions with Northern MPs on matters relating to Northern Ireland and the Good Friday agreement. He goes on to say, on this particular issue - It would also be consistent with Seanad reform that has been discussed for many years. Most importantly, nothing that I would propose will cut across the architecture of the agreement. It can moreover complement the North-South parliamentary forum under the agreement, which we hope to see established soon. I'd suggest those proposals will be carefully scrutinised by several parties. Vital Research Funding in Northern IrelandThe Northern Ireland Chest, Heart and Stroke Association is offering grants, aiming to help combat the illnesses which take 2 out of 3 lives. The grants are only available to projects based in Northern Ireland. As well as the £125,000 going to chest disease research and heart illness research, and the £76,000 going to other study areas, there is £40,000 going to training to help health professionals contribute to the quality of research. The charity's chief executive, Andrew Dougal, said: "We are looking for proposals from researchers in our hospitals and universities offering the quickest possible benefit for patients." The Northern Ireland Chest, Heart and Stroke Association has also recently appointed a Woman’s Heart Nurse whose job will be to provide health checks, advice and support in the community - particularly in deprived areas. Victim's ViewAileen Quinton, whose mother was killed in the 1987 Remembrance Sunday bombing in Enniskillen has decribed her difficulties with recent Government actions in the Belfast News Letter By Aileen Quinton
At the time of the Poppy Day Massacre, all the old clichés were trotted out about how “no stone would be left unturned to bring those responsible to justice” and of course "terrorism does not pay". If only!. This is Groundhog day. Am I meant to be grateful because the IRA says that it is going to stop doing something that it had no right starting? In its statement it justifies its actions. So it will have no compunction in starting up again, when the concessions dry up. Our government shows no sign of stopping this flow at the moment, with moves like watchtowers in border areas being dismantled, the RIR etc. This is not based on an assessment of security requirements but merely because the IRA want it. We also face the prospect of an amnesty for the on-the runs. Even the Belfast Agreement did not include this abomination. Why should my mother’s murder be anyone’s ‘free go’? There have of course been lots of other atrocities as well and not only the IRA will benefit. I draw no comfort from the thought that so called “loyalist” terrorists will have their evil written off too. This does not make the score one all. It makes it two nil to terrorism. So the IRA are talking about stopping something that was wrong, maintaining it was right and which is entirely reversible. Our Government is intent on doing something wrong and irreversible. If the IRA are not a threat anymore, why are we having an amnesty anyway. It can only be because of the fear that without it the IRA will continue to murder, so our government is going to pardon people that even it considers a terrorist threat. Her Majesty’s Government should be in the business of safeguarding victims’ rights to justice, not making a present of it to the murderers. I expect a lot more platitudes about the ‘bigger picture’, ‘the common good’ and “yes, this is difficult for the victims”. But it is for the ‘common good’ that we should not allow the Criminal Justice System to be politicised, especially not at the behest of the criminals. Justice is one of the fundamental building blocks of a peaceful and decent society and the latter cannot be bought by giving away the former. That is like selling the television to pay for the licence. As for it being “difficult”, “difficult” does not matter, We have been doing “difficult” for over 30 years, We can handle “difficult” and would be prepared to do “difficult” for real peace, glad to in fact . This is wrong and it should be impossible. Some will dismiss my opinions as “coloured by her grief”. Well the IRA broke my heart but my intellect and my values are intact. The ultimate victory for terrorism is when we give up on our values. Blair and Hain may have handed theirs over but I’ll be damned if I will.
Extradition row continuesRTE report Taoiseach Bertie Ahern in the Irish Times calling for calm, clear-headed consideration and debate on the issue of the extradition of three men found guilty of training FARC rebels[subs req] in Colombia, meanwhile the BBC has other opinions.. and the Irish Times, along with a barrister's opinion - "Process of extradition is fraught with numerous legal difficulties" - has a statement from a representative of the chairman of the US Congress International Relations Committee, Congressman Henry Hyde - "We hope the Irish Government honours its agreements and carries out the Interpol warrant for these three Irishmen who are wanted on serious charges by the Colombian government after conviction for helping to facilitate the training of narco-terrorists in our own hemisphere." From the Irish Times report Speaking on behalf of committee chairman Congressman Henry Hyde, he said the US hoped the Government had not made a deal with the IRA as the issue "had nothing to do with Northern Ireland" and related to the drug war in the neighbourhood of the US. More of the statement by the representative of Congressman Hyde - "The US takes this issue very seriously. We hope the Irish Government honours its agreements and carries out the Interpol warrant for these three Irishmen who are wanted on serious charges by the Colombian government after conviction for helping to facilitate the training of narco-terrorists in our own hemisphere." Also worth listening to Suzanne Breen on BBC radio's Talkback programme.. on what she describes as the charade around the apparent indecision of Government in regard to the extradition - available online here. [RealPlayer sound file] August 07, 2005Annual Electoral Register Requirement To Be DroppedThe government has published plans for the requirement to register for your vote every year to be amended. Under the proposed plans, the Chief Electoral Officer can decide when the roll needs refreshing. It is also proposed that people should be able to get on the register up until 11 days before an election, in an attempt to up the number of people registered to vote in Northern Ireland. Sinn Fein's national director of elections Pat Doherty MP welcomed the consultation paper and its proposals, calling annual registration a ‘complete disaster’. Looks like it may be back to the Job Centre for Alexandra Ford – the star of the Electoral Commission’s ‘Secure Your Vote – Or Lose It’ campaign Pride Parade Passes PeacefullyThe Parade in Belfast yesterday was one like no other seen in Northern Ireland for the rest of the year. Rainbow balloons, boats, jazz bands, disco dancing and Spiderman on a quad bike – It was Belfast Gay Pride 2005. While many rainbow feet followed the extensive route, protesters from the ‘Stop the Parade Coalition’ stood at City Hall. This year, another Christian group – ‘Zero28’ expressed it’s wish for the anti- Pride groups to cancel their protest. Organisers and Police were pleased that the parade had passed off without incident, but protesters say they will be making an official complaint to the Parade’s Commission, claiming marcher’s shouted abuse at them. Sampling opinionTwo polls have been published today, one in the Sunday Business Post, a telephone canvass of 1,000 voters in the south shows 45% of those responding would be happy to accept Sinn Féin in coalition government and a similar number are now more likely to vote for the party.. “What today's figures show is that the party (SF) is eliminating the “transfer repellency'‘ outside the party's core base of supporters. If this is carried into a general election - even on 10 per cent of the vote - it will return many more Sinn Féin TDs."The other, in the Sunday Independent, surveys reaction of 50 TDs on the call to give elected reps from the north a voice in the Dáil. The Sunday Independent finds, to it's horror I'm sure, almost 50% in favour of some form of representation at this early stage. “But almost half surveyed said they would be in favour of Northern MPs contributing to Oireachtas committees, and even possibly engaging in Seanad sessions.” Orde says unionists doing nothing about loyalist violenceThe Daily Ireland reports that PSNI Chief Constable, Hugh Orde, has been called a "disgrace" by the chairman of the Loyalist Commission over his claim in an e-mail that the police "are the only ones doing anything about the loyalist feud". The Reverend Mervyn Gibson said Orde "doesn't have a clue what he's talking about". "If the PSNI did their job properly, we would not have had this feud in the first place," he said. Meanwhile, another man was shot and wounded in Belfast as the loyalist feud continues. August 06, 2005 Robin Cook 1946-2005Prominent Labour Party MP, former Foreign Secretary and Leader of the Commons, Robin Cook has died after collapsing during a hill-walking holiday in Scotland. Guardian report here Update And some of the tributes from his political colleagues Paisley for the Lords?The Irish Times reports that Eileen Paisley could be on her way to the House of Lords while husband Ian is being tipped for elevation to Queen Elizabeth's Privy Council, enabling him to go by the title "the right honourable member" for North Antrim. Eileen would become a Baroness or Lady, I assume. Colombia to issue extradition warrantThe BBC, and the Associated Press, report the response of Colombian Vice-President Francisco Santos to the sudden re-appearance of James Monaghan and, presumably, the other two men who fled Colombia after being convicted of training FARC - "Irish Prime Minister Bertie Ahern must demonstrate his country's commitment to the global fight against terrorism." Meanwhile, along with the official denials of any deal with SF, the Irish Examiner rounds up the political reaction here.. and the British Government, via the NIO, has stated - "If they enter the UK, any extradition request will be dealt with without delay" August 05, 2005 Loyalist Rioting in BelfastLoyalist Paramilitaries are being blamed for the serious rioting last night in the Crumlin Road area. Reports tell of 10 cars and a bus being hijacked and set alight, petrol bombs being thrown and 40 police officers being hurt. The trouble followed the arrest of 6 men in connection with the ongoing loyalist feud, in which three men have already been murdered. Police in riot gear went to the scene, and 11 baton rounds were fired. Northern Ireland's criminal justice minister David Hanson condemned the violence: "Once again it is loyalist paramilitaries who have brought violence into loyalist areas," Colombia Three back in IrelandRTÉ is reporting that Martin McCauley, Niall Connolly and Jim Monaghan, better know as the Colombia Three, are back in Ireland. First reaction from the DUP is already in with deputy leader Peter Robinson calling on Taoiseach Bertie Ahern to find them and hand them back. Jim Monaghan confirmed to RTÉ that the men had returned to Ireland in the past few days. However, he would not say how they got here. He said that they had got a 'lot of help from a lot of people' and that he would not endanger them. Gardaí crack down on immigration from NIA year on from the referendum to change the Irish Republic's citizenship laws, it has been revealed that 477 people have been refused entry from Northern Ireland to the Irish Republic in the first six months of 2005, an increase of nearly 250% over a year. Thanks Seamus for this even if it's a little late. A special Garda immigration unit based in Dundalk stopped the people in the first six months while in the same period last year, they refused nearly 194. The vast majority are from former Soviet States and have come looking for work but aren't entitled to work permits. The Immigration Border Control Unit was set up last October and has its base in Dundalk as the Belfast to Dublin corridor is regarded as the main route of entry of illegal immigrants. According to Garda Commissioner Noel Conroy in the Irish Times false passports that state the people are from new EU countries such as Latvia or Estonia are used for entry. The head of the Dundalk Unit, Sgt O'Connor, said "very few people" are now putting in asylum applications. Not surprising considering the "safe third country" rule means they are immediately returned to the UK, from whence they came. The Assembly ain't coming backIN the Irish Times, David Adams argues that "It is becoming clearer by the day that the British government believes the political institutions in Northern Ireland cannot be revived." Some excerpts from the article - Whether the judgment is that neither Sinn Féin nor the DUP is genuinely committed to reaching an agreement on power-sharing or, more charitably, that the gulf between them is so wide as to be unbridgeable is largely irrelevant. And he argues that neither Sinn Féin nor the DUP are, in reality, concerned about reinstating the Assembly.. Despite what they may say, neither Sinn Féin nor the DUP will be too discomfited by the prospect of the Assembly not being reinstated. Not least because the government assessment is right: for completely different reasons neither is interested in sharing power with the other. Sinn Féin's, and the DUP's, focus will be in other areas, he says - With or without a working Assembly, Sinn Féin will continue its twin-track policy of creating instability in Northern Ireland while expanding its electoral base in the Republic. And for the rest of us it could be a different form of devolution - Unfortunately, the rest of us will just have to await the long overdue reorganisation of local government in Northern Ireland, with its promise of far fewer but much more powerful local councils, to deliver locally based, representative and accountable, democratic institutions. ..which could also be described as the cantonisation approach. Pictures of home...The pictures on the right are drawn from the Flickr Northern Ireland group. You can have your own photos appear before a global audience, simply by signing up to Flickr and then posting your online snaps to the group. Check out the Ireland and IrishBlogs groups too. Why Blair could deal with IRA...John O'Farrell in the New Statesman believes that Tony Blair was singularly equiped to understand the journey that the IRA could make from violence to peaceful democratic engagement with state, as much from his mother's Donegal background as anything else. Xam Rslts by TxtOne thing summer in Northern Ireland always brings, if not the sun, is exam results. The Scottish Qualifications Authority is ditching ‘snail mail’ in favour of text to deliver results as part of a new pilot scheme being tested in the Western Isles, Orkney and Shetland. Pupils will receive their results only after replying ‘Yes’ to a text from the SQA. Like most mobile services today, the SQA doesn’t manage to give exact details of how much the service will cost pupils. Chris Martin, of the SQA's information technology department, said: "At the end of the day, the experience of our pilot candidates will have a big say as to where we go next with this project." August 04, 2005 Culture watchSome of you may be interested in a play on Radio 4 on Friday named 'Dungannon'. It's the story of a young mother's efforts to get a home for her family in County Tyrone in 1963... more here. Slow summer blogging ahead...Believe it or not, I'm heading off on holiday in a few days. I will continue to blog, but it will be very occasional. I'll be back towards the end of the month to tune in for the new political season in Northern Ireland. In September we'll have news of an exciting new online project, and we hope to have some serious sponsorship for Slugger by then too. In the meantime, if you've enjoyed Slugger and want to help keep us going - please, please put a few bob in the donation box on the left hand side. Or even better, drop me a cheque! Have a good summer all! Engaging democracy over the table?Silly season? Maybe. This new approach to getting people re-engaged with democracy came from reader Alan with a note reading, "obviously trying to link the chattering and the plate clattering classes". The end of (armed) history?Danny Morrison looks at what he believes is the end of a very long era in Irish Republican history. He begins by noting the raggedy start to the IRA's campaing: "Support for the IRA in its defensive role after the pogroms of August 1969 was overwhelming in Belfast. However, support for armed struggle came testily in dribs and drabs". Mowlam critically illA story that broke yesterday that hasnt been covered yet is that former Secretary of State Mo Mowlam is critically ill in hospital. DUP to seek review of Kelly caseIt seems that the DUP is planning to take on the case of Sean Kelly to judicial review, after Peter Hain decided to keep the evidence on which he had ordered Kelly's re-arrest secret. On the ineffectiveness of 'terror'...Quentin Peel, writing in today's FT, argues that despite 'a good result', Sinn Fein should not be allowed to forget (subs needed) the parallels between their own campaign of violence and that being waged in Baghdad, London and other places against innocent people. The IRA move is not just because al-Qaeda has given terrorism a bad name, to put it crudely. That is true, of course. The attacks of September 11 2001 suddenly brought home to ordinary Americans, in particular, that you cannot distinguish between “good” terrorists and “bad” ones. Financial support in the US for Irish republicanism virtually dried up. Ever since, leaders of the IRA and Sinn Féin, their political wing, have been desperate to distance themselves from “global terrorism”. Another Groundhog morning...?Gerry Adams and Ian Paisley meet Tony Blair separately today to tell him why the other is being unreasonable. Adams on the BBC Today programme refered to having "the usual re-cyclable interview" (sound file) with John Humphries. Perhaps most interesting, was Adams' statement that he now had to "accept the authority of the police". August 03, 2005 Never mind the DiplocksIt appears that there is no end to the SoS's generosity in the aftermath of the Historic Statement. Suspected terrorists are to be given the right to jury trial, at precisely the moment when the right is to be withdrawn from certain ODCs. Down south, the policy has, of course been moving in the opposite direction, with the minister hinting that it's not only terrorism, but organused crime which concerns him. Of couse the policy may yet change, not least as the scourge of shinnerdom now appears to be bored with his job. Nicholson to reject Dail dealJim Nicholson has reacted angrily to the Irish governments plans to grant speaking rights to MP's and MEP's from Northern Ireland, calling the decision deplorable. The unionist community will not tolerate such an aggressive assault on our sovereignty by a jurisdiction which has been so hostile in the past.He has in this statement, ruled out taking his seat uder such plans. 'Stupid' struggle?In Tuesday's Guardian, Lionel Shriver claims that "throughout the whole melee, whether Ireland was united never mattered very much, and really doesn't matter now". Not for the first time, she's trying to prick our "collective vanity". By regularly writing about us in international newspapers. Unionists will decide when IRA is sincerePeter Robinson looks back over the IRA's record and finds a plausibility gap between that organisation's words and actions. He also argues that there has been an unseemingly airbrushing of last week's statement's ambiguity in an attempt to fast track political progress in NI. Almost a decade ago the IRA announced it was all over but within a few months the murders and criminality were back on its agenda. Yet again they declared a ceasefire but they failed to cease. They have peppered the recent years with promises and carefully crafted statements. Each of their statements was heralded as groundbreaking and historic by governments and the media but after each the IRA always reverted to what it does best. A few days ago another statement made grand claims about the IRA's intentions. Where it was imprecise or vague in its language its friends in government and the press provided a favourable interpretation permitting the IRA to avoid clarifying for itself. He also notes: The lack of transparency on arms decommissioning and the absolute silence on criminality will significantly prolong the assessment period the community will demand in order that we can judge whether the IRA's war is over for ever and its criminal empire is closed down. Time to get ready for another long wait... "not with a bang but with a self-regarding whim."From yesterday's Irish Times, Fintan O'Toole gives his reaction to the IRA statement - "The most extraordinary thing about the IRA's statement last week is that it shows how much joy has been drained out of the peace process" He argues that the general feeling "of boredom, scepticism and apathy" that met the statement was in part a result of the overtly choreographed presentation - So why was the moment, when it came, so anti-climactic? Why, beyond the realms of a media world delighted to have a story to fill space in the silly season, was the general feeling such a sour compound of boredom, scepticism and apathy? Some of the reasons are obvious enough. People know news management when they see it, and the staging of this event has been painfully transparent. The other part in the reaction, he argues, was the lack of intellectual or moral insight - More profoundly, however, there is a sense of unacknowledged futility. The decision to wind itself up is accompanied by neither intellectual nor moral insight. There is no recognition that, at the very least, the last 20 years of the IRA's campaign was politically counter-productive, no acceptance that a political settlement based on violent coercion was as unattainable as it would have been unsustainable. There is no remorse, no pity, no shame. He asks a question that hasn't been raised elsewhere - namely why was the proposed IRA statement, previously published, in December 2004, in Annex C of the Proposals by the British and Irish Governments for a Comprehensive Agreement [pdf file], not used? That draft included a very carefully calibrated formulation that had obviously been tested and found to be acceptable to both governments and to the other parties in Northern Ireland. It stated that the IRA would accept the "need not to endanger anyone's personal rights or safety". And so... And so, a long history of conspiratorial republicanism comes to an end, not with a bang but with a self-regarding whim. There is nothing eloquent, no sense of grandeur, no epic moment of historical, emotional or moral truth. 'Wrong Man' indicates a maturing festivalIt looks like I'm going to miss the end of the Belfast run of Danny Morrison's play The Wrong Man, which is currently playing in the Conway Mill as part of the Féile an Phobail until this weekend, when it transfers to Edinburgh. Writing in the Irish Times, John O'Farrell reckons the play's relatively unpartisan portrayal of the IRA (subs needed) is an indication of how the Festival itself is slowly loosening itself from the politics of its foundation in 1988. Morrison said that he "did not want to write an apologia for the IRA" or to "mythologise" them. He wanted to show the "humanity" of people who were "flawed, weak individuals". His Provos are cocky, committed, ruthless torturers and murderers. His British squaddies are bored, cheerful, arrogant and efficient. His RUC Special Branch officers are witty, sarcastic, forensic manipulators of time, facts and people. His women characters are frustrated and impoverished widows-in-waiting. If the audience were expecting the theatrical equivalent of a "show of strength", they were disappointed. How nationalism moved away from the gun...Tom McGurk looks at the context of the IRA's armed struggle, and how it has changed to bring Northern Irish nationalists to the point where armed struggle seems besides the point and even inimical to their future prosperity. The peace process has fundamentally changed the Northern economic and cultural landscape and economic and educational demographics have produced a new nationalist population with burgeoning economic power and political expectations. In this context, the IRA had increasingly become an anachronism. As unionists this weekend survey the new post-IRA landscape, they might well consider that they have a unique, unfettered opportunity to do a political deal. No southern representation without taxation?Sam Smyth in the Irish Independent today, reviews past attempts to get Northern Irish representation in the Dail, each of which failed - even when Clann na Poblachta successfully ran its 1948 election campaign on the admission of Northern MPs to the Oireachtas. He wonders why Sinn Fein thinks it can get anywhere this time out: "It is not democracy as we know it". Dissenters must support the stateJust before it gets archived into the Belfast Telegraph site, have a look at this piece from Eric Waugh. He poses some interesting questions about how the IRA might transform into an acceptable, law abiding (if not entirely lawful) peace time organisation. He argues: There must be a law-abiding state provided for a fledgling administration to govern. If the state is lawless, that administration will not survive. But a law-abiding State has as its sine qua non that all its citizens support it, its laws, its institutions and, above all, its constitution for the time being by democracy established. Sinn Fein must "become comrades of mainstream SDLP, the SNP and Plaid Cymru - until such time as the said republicans become persuasive enough to command a convincing electoral majority within this part of the British state". This means that, in the meantime, to become "lawful" they must observe its laws; not oppose the armed forces of the State (within whose ranks, after all, previous generations of republicans have served with distinction); they must join its police force; play a full part in Parliament, according to the will of the electorate; and its representatives accord a modicum of courtesy to the head of state and her family on ceremonial occasions. Finally he argues that if all parties now support the state, the guns become irrelevant. If all parties can find the political will to face down NI's estimated 235 criminal gangs, it will eventually free Northern Ireland of its militarily conflicted past. Anything short of that will simply not work. Can Republicans accept power sharing?In this week's Newsletter column Alex Kane has trouble getting excited about the IRA statement. He argues that the Republican movement is refusing to face some fundamental political truths about Northern Ireland's future, and wonders aloud whether its because it cannot face genuine power sharing with its erstwhile political opponents - the Unionists. By Alex Kane It really is very hard to work up any enthusiasm for the IRA statement. The organisation is still only half-way to where it should have been in 1998. Instead, it spent the next seven years lining its pockets and bullying from the sidelines. And while this particular statement may lack the torturous semantics of its predecessors, it still adds up to in-your-face guff. The IRA has lost and lost big time. The prospect of a United Ireland is as far away today as it was in 1970, when the Provisionals first bombed their way into the headlines; or July, 1972, when Martin McGuinness and Gerry Adams were flown to London for secret talks with the British government. There is no hope of a United Ireland and thirty-five years of ditches, safe houses, hunger strikes and republican propaganda, has led to nothing more than a formal recognition of partition and the opportunity for IRA members to govern Northern Ireland within the United Kingdom. The unionist presence is as strong as it has ever been. This is a victory for the entire pro-Union community, who refused to be bombed, blackmailed or bargained out of their beliefs. The IRA may say that the “armed campaign” is finally over, but the truth of the matter is that the end purpose of that campaign---to remove the British from Ireland---was never a serious prospect. That being the case, the IRA is having to settle for the removal of the watch-towers and the return of its on-the-runs. Again, not much to show for thirty-five years of terror. That is the stark reality underpinning the statement, a reality which seems to have been ignored in the media hoopla and the fatuous response from Tony Blair. Mind you, Blair’s comment that this is “…a step of unparalleled magnitude…” perfectly encapsulates the hypocrisy of the whole thing. It was, after all, the spineless attitude of successive administrations, which encouraged the IRA to believe that its terror campaign could deliver the ultimate dividend of a united Ireland. But the IRA hasn’t gone away. It hasn’t disbanded. It hasn’t apologised. It hasn’t faced up to political reality. It hasn’t made any concessions to unionism or unionists. It justifies the legitimacy of its terrorism. It hasn’t ruled out another campaign at another time. It hasn’t promised to dismantle the paramilitary apparatus, which allows it to keep whole geographical areas and housing estates under its control. It isn’t handing back the money it has stuffed away in numerous secret accounts. In essence, the statement is the same old baloney of finger-pointing self-righteousness. Yet it is precisely because Mr. Blair has interpreted it as being of “unparalleled magnitude” which leads me to believe that it is unionists, rather than Sinn Fein, who will again be pressurised into delivering more concessions, or remain deprived of devolved and fully democratic institutions of government. The appeasement machine has already been cranked up, showering Sinn Fein with face-saving goodies, while reminding unionists of how fickle and surrender-driven the NIO and Number 10 are likely to be. The problem, of course, is that the statement, and the reaction of the British, Irish and American governments, causes huge problems for unionism in general and the DUP in particular. In one fell swoop the IRA has been removed from the equation; but without having been removed from the political undergrowth. The DUP will be told that this is as good as it will get and that the statement should be regarded as a final and definitive one. In other words, the issues of disbanding and disappearing are, as far as the governments are concerned, completely off the political agenda. The DUP has been given a stark choice. Take it or leave it. They will be given another stark choice in a few weeks time---talk to Sinn Fein directly about re-establishing devolution, or forget about devolution for the forseeable future. The DUP has very little room for manoeuvre and it will not be allowed to drag out the process for very much longer. Putting it bluntly, Tony Blair, having found it, is not going to risk losing the Holy Grail of every Prime Minister since 1968, the ending of republican violence. Sinn Fein, it must be remembered, has problems of its own. P.O’Neill has written of the IRA’s decision to “…advance our republican and democratic objectives, including our goal of a united Ireland. We believe there is now an alternative way to achieve this and to end British rule in our country.” There is no such alternative. The pro-Union majority is not going to be out-bred or out-voted and Northern Ireland is not going to be evicted from the United Kingdom. Northern Ireland has come a very long way since 1995. It has still a very long way to go. The whole process could move much faster if Sinn Fein and the IRA had the courage to abandon rhetoric and embrace political reality. Unionism, all of it, has accepted the reality of power-sharing and the Irish dimension as the price to be paid for devolution. Are republicans wilfully or psychologically incapable of accepting power-sharing and the British dimension? If so, then the IRA’s statement will, as I suspect, amount to no more than another false dawn in the peace process.
Historic movement of troops out of UlsterOperation Banner comes to an end thirty five years after the British government first ordered the Army into Northern Ireland to provide backup for the then RUC. They were first sent onto the streets in August 1969, although the numbers in barracks had been building up from at least the previous month. August 02, 2005 There is one born every second*[*Title stolen shamelessly from the excellent Harry's Place] Part 1 of Technorati's report on The State of the Blogosphere [Haven't we banned the use of the term blogosphere? - Ed] is out.. According to their figures, a new blog appears every second and overall blog numbers are doubling every 5.5months.. In addition about 55% of all blogs are considered active [had a posting in the last 3 months] and 13% of all blogs update at least weekly.. importantly, IMO, according to the BBC report "What is clear is that the blogosphere [Ahem - Ed] is highly varied" There's more to come from the report over the week.. and here's the caveat, from Technorati's Dave Sifry, with these stats - Tomorrow I'll give an update on posting volume, which is a better statistic to track the growth of blogging. Lots of people who start new blogs are kicking tires and thus the numbers displayed above could be indicative of a fad in progress - but watching the posting volume shows how many people are actually blogging on a day-by-day basis. I think that is a much better indicator that people are making blogging a habit and a part of their daily lives. Getting beyond the Unification question?Roy Garland argues that there are more ways than one for the peoples of Ireland to get together than out and out political unification of the island. Already the Council of the Isles , he argues, "has the capacity to transcend petty squabbles and usher in a new era of goodwill and cooperation on an unprecedented scale. Northern Ireland as a political entity can continue to exist, but in a dynamic relationship with an Irish state and a devolved Great Britain". Right back at ya!Via maca's comment in an entirely unrelated post at United Irelander.. Over at the BBC On-line Magazine, Alan Connor's Weblog Watch has a round-up of Irish blogs' reaction to the IRA statement.. and other posts.. you'll probably recognise some familiar names there. Devil's in detail of long negotiations ahead...Good old Newshound. John has Frank Millar's analysis in the Irish Times from Saturday. He's not buying the Gerry has sold out on the revolution line. Instead he believes the seemingly never-ending process will continue, and make the next tranche of negotiations much more complex and problematic for all parties. I have never been persuaded that Gerry Adams is lying to himself or to his own people. There have certainly been seismic shifts in republican attitudes and strategies. But there is no evidence of a republican willingness to invest in a process would either legitimise or stabilise the British state in Northern Ireland. That is why the DUP is making a huge mistake in thinking that it is only the actions of IRA volunteers (and they haven't gone away, you know) which matter. As Michael McDowell grasped all to well last December, the language is vital too. Pods and blogs...I doubt whether many of you will have been up late enough to hear this programme on Pods and Blogs on BBC Radio Five last night (I wasn't). They asked me to do a quick sketch on the elections last week - 6.45 mins in from the start. It's worth running through if you are interested in the podcasting revolution - it's the next big thing, apparently! Huge breadth of interests from Indian politics to knitting. DUP lines up with its own conditionsThe DUP lays out some of its own conditions before any face to face contact will made with Sinn Fein: The DUP is demanding that the requirement for a "mandatory" coalition administration underpinned by legislation should be dropped. It wants changes on how the First and Deputy First Ministers are appointed and greater accountability built into a new Assembly format. Thanks to reader Dave! Chronic lack of cultural investmentIan McGarry, Equity general secretary has put a proposal in front of Peter Hain to tackle what he terms the general lack of investment in Northern Irish culture and arts. He is critical of several players in the field. “For decades there has been under-investment, which perhaps was understandable when it was hard even to take film crews on location in Northern Ireland, given the situation. But we think the circumstances are there now for investment to go ahead.” EU pressure forces change in Irish intellectual property lawsRTE reports on how the proposed changes in the public lending right payments system will affect public libraries, but as Irish author Philip Casey points out on his blog "The cheque will hardly be worth collecting for 99% of authors". He suggests that the Artists' Resale Right payments system, and the commitment to enforce intellectual property rights [details at the DETE site], will have a greater impact. The Irish Examiner seems to agree - "The plans will include greater protection against counterfeiting and piracy and will also provide for extra payments to artists whose work is sold on by future owners." Government scaling down security measuresThe big news yesterday was the cutting of British Army strengths and the remaindering of the home sections of the RIR (formerly the UDR, which attracted up to 18% Catholic recruits in its earliest days). The second decision in particular has attracted, major criticism. However, it was expected in most political quarters. August 01, 2005 The making of internet terrorists...There are plenty of reports about the power of blogging and how the disaggreation of official newsflows can change the citizen's relationship to information, and the state. John Lloyd looks at how some young British Muslims are being radicalised by website's run from 1000's of miles away - mostly without any knowledge of parents, family, neighbours or friends. Refering to some of the Yorkshire based London bombers: These young murderers were that new phenomenon, terrorist nerds. Night after night, they click on to Islamic websites and live a life of virtual resentment and hatred, burning ever hotter with indignation over what has been or is being done to Muslims in Afghanistan, Chechnya, Palestine and Iraq. Images of horrors perpetrated on one's nation, tribe or community have played a role in stimulating the murderous instincts of would-be combatants for centuries. In contrast with previous campaigns, the internet makes a crucial difference: Now, the one who prepares mentally to kill himself and as many of the godless as he can does a crucial part of his training gazing impassively at images of Muslims slaughtered by Americans, British, Indians and Russians, or the sado-porn amateur snaps from Abu Ghraib. What would a community worker, a friend or, for that matter, a mother see but a young man, scrolling through images and text, betraying no emotion? Journalists, who do this for large parts of their day, might understand the phenomenon at least as well as anyone. John Battle, the MP for Leeds West - his constituency abuts Beeston - used a striking image to describe what happens when people get their information from the web. He said that it was as if a coherent picture had been painted on glass, and the glass then shattered, then some shards of the shattered glass put together in an arbitrary way, according to the dictates of a mind prompted to create an impregnable carapace of grieving hatred. "a sophisticated, resourceful and multi-million-dollar criminal enterprise"When Ed Moloney gave his initial reaction to the IRA statement, on RTE's News at One he was met with a barrage of ad hominem attacks from SF ally Niall O'Dowd and, more particularly, former Taoiseach Albert Reynolds - listen here. Moloney expanded on the theme in an Irish Examiner article the following day, and the Sunday Herald carried another astute article by him yesterday "No matter what was in the IRA statement of this week, there can be little doubt that these activities [IRA criminality] will continue, and may even intensify.".. it's an issue on which, according to the only available poll, 87% of people seem to agree with him. NI's curate egg economy...The Observer notes that low unemployment, high consumer spending and rising house prices have all brought a feeling of well being to the NI economy. However, in the FT, John Murray Brown looks at some of the a underlying structural problems that remain to be tackled: Pat McArdle, chief economist at Ulster Bank, now part of Royal Bank of Scotland, told this year's annual CBI Northern Ireland lunch that the region looked set to underperform the UK as a whole for the first time for several years, growing at rates closer to the eurozone. A Republican 'Catch 22'?One Tim Hames, writing in today's London Times, looks ahead to a 'win-win' scenario for Sinn Fein in which it will (he believes) "decommission the SDLP even faster than General John de Chastelain and his team can dismantle the IRA’s arsenal". But the rub, for those fundamentalists still within modern Sinn Fein may be the shift away from the headline terms of the war (severing the link Britain), to a new imperative under conditions of peace and democracy: The more effective that Sinn Fein is as an electoral force, the more impotent it becomes as an ideological one. Every deal it strikes with Tony Blair legitimises the British presence in Northern Ireland. Every concession it secures that advances the economic and social standing of ordinary Roman Catholics in Ulster weakens the argument that it is only through Irish unification that those material interests can be realised. With every step that Ulster takes towards becoming a “normal society”, so what Sinn Fein officially regards as an “interim settlement” becomes more deeply entrenched. Blair's racialist view of terrorism?Geoffrey Wheatcroft with a fierce critique of Tony Blair's apparently contradictory stance on the Northern Irish peace process, and his more combative and aggressive approach to terrorism in Britain. He concludes: If there is no moral distinction between Adams and al-Zarqawi, and Adams's objectives are certainly no more honourable or rational than al-Zarqawi's, there is one objective difference: Adams is white. No doubt Tony Blair doesn't consciously think in terms of 'darkies' or Mahometan savages, but the grim and very dangerous truth is that the terrorists he will never negotiate with or give an inch to are Asian by birth or descent and Muslim by religion, whereas the terrorists he propitiates are Catholic, Aryan, white Europeans. RIR Home Service to be disbandedIt is being reported this afternoon that the GOC NI has announced that the Home Service Battalions of the Royal Irish Regiment are to be disbanded. Well done the DUP, clearly concessions to republicanism have stopped since they are providing leadership that's working! UPDATE: Sir Reg Empey has issued his response. Predictably the DUP hides its embarrassment at further concessions to Republicans by trying to blame the UUP for this decision. This is lies. Let us not forget that for nearly 2 years the DUP has been the larger Unionist party and promised people that if they voted for them concessions would stop. The last few months have shown this to be a false promise. Apparently Mr Blair didn’t even inform the DUP about this decision. New vistas opening for Sinn Fein?Morning Ireland had an excellent snippet on this morning with a detail examination of the party's election prospects in the wake of the IRA's suspension of it's military campaign from Fionnan Sheehan of the Irish Examiner, and Cian McCormick talks to three TDs on how their parties might consider the possibility of Sinn Fein as a prospective coalition partner in future. Most are cagey, but given the IRA acquits itself well over time ahead there were no objections in priniciple. It was also the subject of a leader in today's Guardian. Loyalists out of step with changes?With another death attributed to Loyalist paramilitaries over the weekend, the end of the IRA campaign is throwing light on that (lesser known) side of the paramilitary equation. Henry McDonald's excellent piece in the Observer magazine yesterday, details exactly how the shady world of Loyalist paramilitarism has moved from its heartland and into North Down's 'Gold Coast' - with tragic results for at least one family. The Dorrians are Catholics living in a village that is largely Protestant, on the edge of a seaside unionist town that has been relatively untouched by 35 years of incipient civil war. They stress that during that time they were never subjected to abuse or violence, even in the darkest days of the conflict. Later, McDonald notes the action being taken by the UVF, a rival to the LVF - the organisation widely suspected of her disappearnence: Meanwhile, the UVF has set up its own 'inquiry' into Lisa's disappearance, which is running in parallel with the official police investigation. In a macabre twist to the tragedy, and apparently without irony, the UVF has appointed convicted murderer Samuel Cooke to head its 'investigation'. He was one of five loyalists jailed in 1994 for the sectarian murder of 26-year-old Catholic mother Anne Marie Smyth in 1992. Her killers strangled her and cut her throat, after she was lured to a party in east Belfast by a group of UVF men drinking in a local loyalist social club. "in an enabling environment"Secretary of State for NI [and Wales], Peter Hain, has gone back to the future and published an updated Annex to the April 2003 Joint Declaration [pdf file] by the British and Irish Governments outlining the, ostensibly, two-year plan for normaisation of security - "Providing the enabling environment is established and maintained this programme will be achievable within two years though if the conditions are right to move more quickly in implementing elements of the plan, the Government will do so." Update to Annex 1 of the Joint Declaration This paper provides the updated version of the normalisation programme which was promised in the Government’s statement of 28 July. Empey threats...AS we await the fourth (and final?) act of IRA decommissioning, Unionist leader Sir Reg Empey has threatened to introduce sanctions - his party will refuse to co-operate with North-South bodies set up under the Agreement - if Northern Irish politicians are granted speaking rights in the Irish parliament, the Dail. Sir Reg said: "As you may recall when the deal with Sinn Fein was not completed last December, I said this was outside the terms of the Good Friday Agreement and it was a breach of the principle that the consent of the majority of the people of Northern Ireland would be required before there is any change to our constitutional status. "I believe this move is very dangerous because it would effectively be setting up an embryonic all-Ireland Parliament. "When the idea was first mooted two years ago, the UUP opposed it. We told the two governments then and have repeatedly since that if it is pursued by Dublin, we will no longer be obligated to our support for north south institutions." The discontent of Sir RegSaturdays Newsletter carried a platform piece by Sir Reg Empey in which he outlined his concerns for the future. His concern over Dail speaking rights for Northern MP's and MEP's is shared it seems by Andrew McCann (praise indeed). The Party has since its release been explicit in its distrust of the IRA statement. |
Slugger O'Toole records news, commentary and diverse opinion on Northern Ireland. Produced by Mick Fealty News, tips or crits here: mick.fealty -at- gmail.com Topics a long peace?books Britain Conflict Culture Economy Education election 2003 Election 2005 Enviroment environment Europe Gaeilge Glossary Government Highlights Human Rights Humour International Manifesto Media Nationalism Negotiations Parties Policing Soapbox Society Sport the south unionism
Highlights
Out with the crystal ball...Just a Mo... Commenting Policy A backgrounder on the McCartney affair Northern Bank raid and political fallout, so far
Readers comments
More corrupt than last year? - (4)Living on an island or in a state? - (31) a combination of historical ignorance and monumental self-pity - (42) Payout time... - (4) New Lansdowne revealed - (24) Far right 'imagination'... - (13) Nazi comments were a sectarian slur - (3) The price of peacemaking... - (17) belfast metropolitan area plan unveiled - (23) Why (or rather how) Alec Reid was right... - (37)
Archives
October 2005September 2005 August 2005 July 2005 June 2005 May 2005 April 2005 March 2005 February 2005 January 2005 December 2004 November 2004 October 2004 September 2004 July 2004 March 2004 October 2003 September 2003 May 2003 |
|
Design: River Path Associates Comments: Big Blog Co Powered:
Movable Type 3.15 Copyright © 2003 Sluggerotoole.com
All rights reserved.
|