Slugger O'Toole Notes on Northern Ireland politics and culture Slugger O'Toole Notes on Northern Ireland politics and culture

You are here
Home | Government | Is anybody listening?


Next or Previous
« Botanic Inn 'supporters' let Northern Ireland down... | Main | McCartneys to take campaign online...? »




SOS - Save Our Slugger!

Help fund Slugger's new software:

Or mail it direct to Slugger!



Is anybody listening?
DOES the Government follow or lead public opinion in Northern Ireland? Mark Devenport wonders if we are being consulted too much by Ministers who are supposed to be taking decisions as well as finding out what every special interest group, lobbyist and crank thinks. Is the electorate just a big focus group for the Direct Misrulers... or do they even listen anyway? Leave your considered views below - someone might be reading...

Comments (12)

As usual an outstanding article by Mr Devenport.

His only mistake comes at the very end:

even if the cynics believe that ministers and civil servants always find a way of pressing ahead with the policies they had in mind before launching their consultation exercises.

No. Civil Servants always find a way of pressing ahead with the policy of doing nothing, on the basis that they can't do something because somebody somewhere objects to each possible option.

The whole objective is to avoid acting at all.

Posted by: IJP [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 28, 2005 02:44 PM


Judging by the football supporters and the Ulster Rugby supporters responses to plans for a new stadium at the Maze, they don't listen at all.

Posted by: Everything Ulster (formerly Beano) [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 28, 2005 02:50 PM


Sometimes it does seem like a farce, like consultation on water charges when we all know the Government will push it through anyway as a means of softening up the industry for privatisation. It's a joke.

And you're right about the stadium - sure I did a story on Slugger months ago that it was going to the Maze site.

Consultation is only carried out if it suits the NIO's plans. I'm surprised anyone still takes it seriously.

Posted by: Belfast Gonzo [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 28, 2005 03:29 PM


I know gonzo, I read it. It was around then I originally heard of the plans first (since the assembly was dissolved anyway).

Officially the stadium isn't going anywhere yet, in fact with the pulling out of Ulster Rugby, I wouldn't be surprised if it ground to a halt.

But the government have said they're weighing up 3 sites, and I think the public should challenge them and take them at their word. Perhaps if/when the stadium goes to the Maze it will be a good example to illustrate what a farce this crop of direct misrule ministers are.

Posted by: Everything Ulster (formerly Beano) [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 28, 2005 03:53 PM


Officially the stadium isn't going anywhere yet, in fact with the pulling out of Ulster Rugby, I wouldn't be surprised if it ground to a halt.

Are Rugby officially pulling out? As far as GAA are concerned, I don't know of anybody with any enthusiasm for the project. The GAA have enough stadia of their own and I don't see how this project will benefit the organisation in any way, shape or form.

Posted by: PS [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 28, 2005 04:02 PM


This is going way OT...

Belfast Telegraph report: Officially they are still behind it, but while saying "we need to maintain our home for rugby football in Ulster, which is Ravenhill."

A rugby fan poster at OWC said "It would now appear that the Government have to accept that Ulster Rugby are unable to play their 10 Celtic League games anywhere but Ravenhill and indeed of the European Cup Ulster have confirmed it would only be a big Q-F that would see them take advantage of the National Stadium."

Without rugby, there is no way of getting the magic 30 games/year.

The Direct Misrulers haven't come out and said anything regarding this yet, and what it means for the stadium. No big surprise there. It would seem, as IJP said, inaction is always preferable to action.

Posted by: Everything Ulster (formerly Beano) [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 28, 2005 04:37 PM


PS

Officially the stadium isn't going anywhere yet, in fact with the pulling out of Ulster Rugby, I wouldn't be surprised if it ground to a halt.

Correct.

That was the plan all along.

Beano

It would seem, as IJP said, inaction is always preferable to action.

Correct. As I warned, the whole plan all along with the stadium was to offer it in an unacceptable location, get people like yourself to oppose it, and then not build it at all.

Mark my words.

Posted by: IJP [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 28, 2005 06:46 PM


Does it really need 30 games? Well from what I remember the GAA only promised 3, and even that would be a stretch so the soccer lads better get the Home Nations Championship reformed quick sharp!

Posted by: PS [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 28, 2005 07:23 PM


Will the new stadium be the NI version of the 'Millenium Dome".

Posted by: factfinder [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 28, 2005 07:30 PM


Getting back to "Is Anybody Listening" I'd suggest that Northerners shouldn't feel too special. I'm sure American, European, mainland Britsh, and definitely voters down South in the Irish Republic have been drawing the same conclusions for quite a long time now. What took Mark Davenport so long?

Posted by: joedavis [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 28, 2005 11:29 PM


factfinder

No, they actually built the Millennium Dome.

A properly thought-out stadium would be more like Millennium Stadium than Millennium Dome. But we in NI don't do 'properly thought-out'.

Joe

Hardly. The Irish Republic has seen fundamental and progressive changes to social policy, the development of a vast motorway network, and an advanced mixed economic policy. NI could get none of this, because no one, at least no one elected, is doing any thinking.

Posted by: IJP [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 29, 2005 12:34 AM


Too cynical, Mr Devenport.

I'm not sure whether I represent a special interest group, am simply a lobbyist or am merely a crank ( probably all three), but there is an inbuilt need for people to have their say on all those 61 issues. It is unfortunate that the assembly is not up and running, because those issues are real political issues for real people.

You can only make a difference by getting involved in the process. The recent decision to review our draft Disability Discrimination Order in the light of substantial amendments to the GB legislation is a case in point. I also understand that progressive changes to the Accessible Transport Strategy are on their way. These are the fruits of involvement in consultation and lobbying.

Now to get back to the importance of having just 7 Councils . . .

Posted by: Alan [TypeKey Profile Page] at March 29, 2005 07:03 AM



NOTE: When adding hyperlinks, please follow this format:
<a href="(URL)">hyperlink</a>
It is important that you include http:// when adding the URL.

Slugger O'Toole records news, commentary and diverse opinion on Northern Ireland.

Produced by Mick Fealty
Designed by River Path

News, tips or crits here: mick.fealty -at- gmail.com
(change "-at-" to "@")

Commenting Policy


Topics
a long peace?
books
Britain
Conflict
Culture
Economy
Education
election 2003
Election 2005
Enviroment
environment
Europe
Gaeilge
Glossary
Government
Highlights
Human Rights
Humour
International
Manifesto
Media
Nationalism
Negotiations
Parties
Policing
Soapbox
Society
Sport
the south
unionism

Highlights
Out with the crystal ball...
Just a Mo...
Commenting Policy
A backgrounder on the McCartney affair
Northern Bank raid and political fallout, so far

Readers comments
More corrupt than last year? - (4)
Living on an island or in a state? - (31)
a combination of historical ignorance and monumental self-pity - (42)
Payout time... - (4)
New Lansdowne revealed - (24)
Far right 'imagination'... - (13)
Nazi comments were a sectarian slur - (3)
The price of peacemaking... - (17)
belfast metropolitan area plan unveiled - (23)
Why (or rather how) Alec Reid was right... - (37)


Archives
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
July 2004
March 2004
October 2003
September 2003
May 2003



Design: River Path Associates Comments: Big Blog Co Powered: Movable Type 3.15 Copyright © 2003 Sluggerotoole.com All rights reserved.